Question 1
30 marksRemind yourself of 'Night' by Alice Munro in the Pearson Edexcel International GCSE English Anthology.
How does the writer present the narrator's father in 'Night'?
In your answer, you should write about:
- his appearance and behaviour on the morning she meets him
- the older narrator's thoughts about his strictness and his own troubles
- the use of language and structure.
You should refer closely to the text to support your answer. You may include brief quotations.
Model answer
Munro presents the narrator's father as a reserved, practical and strict man of his time, but one who, at a crucial moment, shows quiet wisdom and kindness, and whose own hidden troubles make him an intriguing figure.
He appears late in the story, sitting on the stoop before dawn, looking towards town and smoking a cigarette he has rolled himself. He is wearing dark work trousers, a rough dark shirt and boots. These precise details make him solid and ordinary. Yet the older narrator later wonders why he was not in his overalls, and realises his clothes suggest some early-morning business away from home. This small observation hints that something lies behind his presence there.
His behaviour is gentle in a restrained way. He greets her with 'good morning', and the narrator explains that such greetings were not normally used in their family. His choice to use one suggests a deliberate softness. He is observant: she realises he must have heard her on many nights, because a man responsible for the livestock, the family's earnings and a handgun kept in his desk would wake at the slightest noise. This list presents him as a watchful provider. He is also tactful. He asks only 'Having trouble sleeping?' and does not pry; the narrator says that if he had hinted he expected more, she would have told him nothing.
His response to her confession reveals wisdom. When she says she is afraid she might strangle her sister, he says simply 'Well.', then tells her not to worry: people sometimes have 'those kinds of thoughts'. He explains it as perhaps 'An effect of the ether' and compares the likelihood of her acting on it to a meteor striking their house. The homely comparison makes his reassurance concrete. He neither mocks her nor shows alarm, and does not blame her. His plain, practical manner is exactly what she needs.
Yet Munro does not idealise him. The older narrator recalls his use of the 'razor strap' and belt to punish her when she was a mouthy child, and suggests he would have justified it by saying she thought herself 'too smart'. The dry, ironic tone of this passage shows a man shaped by the harsh discipline of his time, unlikely to feel the doubts that modern parents feel.
The ending deepens his character. The narrator imagines possible reasons for his being up and dressed that morning: an appointment at the bank to hear that his loan would not be extended because his business was failing, the discovery that her mother's shakiness had a name and would not stop, or even that he had fallen hopelessly for a woman he could never have. The repeated 'Or' turns him into a mystery, a private man carrying burdens his daughter never knew about. This makes his calm response to her more admirable: whatever his own worries, he set them aside for her.
Structurally, the father is placed at the climax of the story, and the reflections on his strictness and his troubles follow his kindness, complicating our view. Munro's portrait is balanced and humane, showing a man both harsh and wise, known and unknowable.
Explanation
Strong answers present the father as a complex figure - reserved, observant, tactful and wise, but also a strict disciplinarian with hidden troubles - and analyse the clothing details, the unusual greeting, the list of responsibilities, his understated speech, the ironic account of punishments and the speculative list of his worries. They recognise that Munro does not idealise him. Weaker answers describe only his kindness in the conversation.
Mark scheme
-
12 marks
Levels of response (12 marks). AO1 (understanding and interpretation).
Level 1 (1-3 marks): Basic selection of information and ideas; limited use of quotations or textual references; limited understanding, likely shown through retelling or paraphrase.
Level 2 (4-6 marks): Some selection of valid information and ideas; some use of valid quotations or references; some valid interpretation showing a developing understanding.
Level 3 (7-9 marks): Clear and relevant selection of information, ideas and perspectives; clear and relevant use of supporting quotations and references; relevant interpretation showing a clear understanding.
Level 4 (10-12 marks): Detailed and persuasive selection of information, ideas and perspectives; discriminating use of supporting quotations and references; perceptive interpretation showing a convincing understanding.
0 marks: no rewardable material.Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid points): The father is found sitting on the stoop before dawn, looking towards town, smoking a cigarette he has rolled himself. He is dressed in dark work trousers (not quite overalls), a rough dark shirt and boots, which the older narrator later notices are a little smarter than his everyday work clothes, suggesting an early errand of some kind. He greets her with an unusual 'good morning'. He is observant: he has clearly heard her walking on many nights, as a man responsible for livestock, money and a handgun in his desk would. He is tactful: he does not pry or hint that he expects more, so she can choose to talk. He is calm and practical: when she confesses her fear of strangling her sister, he responds seriously but without alarm, telling her people sometimes have such thoughts, that it is like a dream, perhaps caused by the ether used in hospital, and as unlikely as a meteor hitting the house. He does not blame her. The older narrator recalls that he used the razor strap and belt to punish her, believing she needed curbing because she thought herself too smart, and that he would probably not have regretted this. She speculates about why he was up and dressed that way: perhaps a bank appointment to hear that his loan would not be extended because his business was failing; perhaps learning that her mother's shakiness had a name and would not stop; perhaps a hopeless love for a woman he could never have. Valid interpretations: he is a man of his time - strict, reserved and burdened - yet wise and kind in this moment; his own troubles make his calm more admirable; the narrator's portrait mixes gratitude, criticism and mystery. Marking notes: AO1 rewards understanding and interpretation of the text in relation to the question focus, supported by apt references. A response that mainly retells the story stays in Level 1 or low Level 2. Accept references and quotations from the anthology text, and accurate paraphrase.
-
18 marks
Levels of response (18 marks). AO2 (analysis of language and structure).
Level 1 (1-3 marks): Limited identification of language and/or structural devices; limited selection of references or examples; basic, simple comment on effects.
Level 2 (4-6 marks): Some identification of language and/or structural devices; some accurate references or examples; some developing comment on effects.
Level 3 (7-10 marks): Clear and relevant selection of language and structural devices; relevant, generally appropriate references and examples; clear explanation of the effects of language and structure.
Level 4 (11-14 marks): Thorough and confident selection of language and structural devices; confident and detailed use of references and examples; detailed exploration of the effects of language and structure.
Level 5 (15-18 marks): Subtle and discriminating selection of language and structural devices; discriminating and assured use of references and examples; perceptive analysis of the effects of language and structure.
0 marks: no rewardable material.Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid points): Precise description of clothing and the hand-rolled cigarette makes him ordinary and grounded; the later question about why he was not in his overalls invites speculation. The narrator's comment that 'good morning' was not usual in the family shows his greeting as a deliberate act of gentleness. The list of his responsibilities - the livestock, the earnings close by, the handgun in his desk - presents him as a watchful provider. His short speech ('Having trouble sleeping?', 'Stupid question') is plain and slightly awkward. His reply 'Well.' and 'those kinds of thoughts' show understatement and acceptance. The homely comparison with a meteor makes his reassurance concrete. The phrase 'without either mockery or alarm' sums up his tone. The reference to the 'razor strap' and to his likely view that she was 'too smart' presents a harsh, traditional disciplinarian, described in a dry, ironic tone. The speculative list of possible troubles (the bank, the mother's illness, an impossible love) uses the repeated 'Or' to suggest mystery and depth. Structure: the father appears only near the end, as the climax of the narrator's night walks; reflections on his punishments come after his kindness, complicating the portrait; the final speculation reveals him as a private man with burdens of his own. Marking notes: AO2 rewards analysis of how language and structure create effects; naming a device without explaining its effect earns little. Levels 3-5 expect comment on both language and structure. Brief, well-chosen quotations are better than long ones.