Question 1
30 marksRemind yourself of 'Whistle and I'll Come to You' by Susan Hill in the Pearson Edexcel International GCSE English Anthology.
How does the writer present the supernatural in 'Whistle and I'll Come to You'?
In your answer, you should write about:
- the cry of the child on the marsh
- the presence on the landing and the nursery
- the use of language and structure.
You should refer closely to the text to support your answer. You may include brief quotations.
Model answer
Hill presents the supernatural not through visible ghosts but through sounds, sensations and the narrator's growing uncertainty, so that it feels both tragic and deeply unsettling.
From the start, the storm seems almost alive. The wind moans down the chimneys and whistles through every gap, and later it is 'like a banshee', a spirit of Irish folklore whose wailing announces a death. The simile blurs the line between natural and supernatural, so that before any ghost appears, the house already feels haunted.
The child's cry is the first clear supernatural sign. It comes out of the darkness on the marsh, and the narrator recognises it as a familiar cry of 'desperation and anguish', a cry for help. The abstract nouns stress suffering rather than threat: this ghost is pitiful as well as frightening. The narrator insists, 'There was no child.', a short, emphatic sentence that shows his rational mind asserting itself. Yet the rhetorical questions that follow - how could he ignore even the crying of a long-dead ghost? - reveal that he does believe in it. When he thinks 'Rest in peace', he immediately recognises that this spirit cannot rest. The idea of a restless child, still crying for help after many years, makes the supernatural tragic.
The presence on the landing is even more disturbing because it is felt rather than seen. Hill describes what the narrator did not experience: no movement, 'no brush of a sleeve', no disturbance of the air, no footstep. This negation creates a paradox - there is nothing, and yet he has an absolute certainty that someone has passed him. The presence goes down the short, narrow corridor to the nursery, whose locked door had mysteriously opened. These precise details make the haunting specific and claustrophobic, and connect the ghost to childhood, as the nursery is a room for children. The narrator also links it to the rocking he has heard.
Hill then shows the supernatural attacking reason itself. The narrator tries to explain the presence: perhaps someone is hiding in the nursery, perhaps it is the woman in black, perhaps Mrs Drablow had a secret companion. His mind produces 'wild, incoherent fantasies', but they collapse when he admits there is no living person in the house except himself and the dog. Whatever is there is not real in any ordinary sense, and he begins to 'doubt my own reality'. The supernatural is frightening because it makes him question his own mind.
Structurally, the supernatural escalates from a sound, to a presence, to a crisis of belief, yet it is never confirmed. The reader, like the narrator, is left uncertain, especially since he was in a trance-like state just before the cry. The extract ends with the child's cry carried on the gusts towards him, returning to the storm with which it began. The haunting is not explained or resolved, which makes it linger in the reader's mind.
Explanation
High-level answers show that Hill's supernatural is suggested rather than shown - through sound, negation and doubt - and analyse the banshee simile, the pitiful language of the cry, the tension between 'There was no child' and the narrator's belief, the list of negatives and the collapse of rational explanation. They note that the ghosts seem tragic as well as threatening. Weaker answers retell the events as 'a ghost appears' without exploring how uncertainty is created.
Mark scheme
-
12 marks
Levels of response (12 marks). AO1 (understanding and interpretation).
Level 1 (1-3 marks): Basic selection of information and ideas; limited use of quotations or textual references; limited understanding, likely shown through retelling or paraphrase.
Level 2 (4-6 marks): Some selection of valid information and ideas; some use of valid quotations or references; some valid interpretation showing a developing understanding.
Level 3 (7-9 marks): Clear and relevant selection of information, ideas and perspectives; clear and relevant use of supporting quotations and references; relevant interpretation showing a clear understanding.
Level 4 (10-12 marks): Detailed and persuasive selection of information, ideas and perspectives; discriminating use of supporting quotations and references; perceptive interpretation showing a convincing understanding.
0 marks: no rewardable material.Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid points): The supernatural is first suggested by the storm, whose noises seem almost alive. The child's cry comes from the darkness out on the marsh: a desperate cry for help that the narrator recognises as familiar, implying he has heard it before. He knows there is no real child and calls it the crying of a long-dead ghost; he thinks it should rest in peace, but it does not and cannot, suggesting a restless, tormented spirit. He feels helpless because nobody has been able to help this child for many years. On the landing he senses someone pass him and go down the corridor to the nursery, whose locked door had mysteriously opened; he connects this presence with the rocking he has heard. He considers rational explanations - someone hiding in the nursery, the woman in black, a secret companion of Mrs Drablow - but rejects them: there is no living person in the house except himself and the dog, so whatever is there is not real in the ordinary sense. The supernatural makes him doubt reality itself. The extract ends with the cry still carried on the wind. Valid interpretations: Hill's supernatural is suggested rather than shown, which makes it more frightening; the ghosts seem tragic as well as threatening; the supernatural is linked with childhood, loss and the nursery; the narrator's state of mind (half asleep, in a trance) leaves room for doubt. Marking notes: AO1 rewards understanding and interpretation of the text in relation to the question focus, supported by apt references. A response that mainly retells the story stays in Level 1 or low Level 2. Accept references and quotations from the anthology text, and accurate paraphrase.
-
18 marks
Levels of response (18 marks). AO2 (analysis of language and structure).
Level 1 (1-3 marks): Limited identification of language and/or structural devices; limited selection of references or examples; basic, simple comment on effects.
Level 2 (4-6 marks): Some identification of language and/or structural devices; some accurate references or examples; some developing comment on effects.
Level 3 (7-10 marks): Clear and relevant selection of language and structural devices; relevant, generally appropriate references and examples; clear explanation of the effects of language and structure.
Level 4 (11-14 marks): Thorough and confident selection of language and structural devices; confident and detailed use of references and examples; detailed exploration of the effects of language and structure.
Level 5 (15-18 marks): Subtle and discriminating selection of language and structural devices; discriminating and assured use of references and examples; perceptive analysis of the effects of language and structure.
0 marks: no rewardable material.Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid points): Personification and animal imagery give the storm a supernatural quality: the wind moans and whistles, and is 'like a banshee', a spirit whose wailing foretells death. The cry is described with abstract nouns ('desperation and anguish'), stressing suffering rather than menace. The short, emphatic 'There was no child.' is undercut by rhetorical questions, showing reason and belief in conflict. The phrase 'Rest in peace' and the narrator's sense that this spirit cannot rest suggest a tormented ghost. The presence is created through negation (no movement, 'no brush of a sleeve', no footstep), so the supernatural is felt rather than seen. Precise setting details (the short, narrow corridor, the nursery, the door locked then inexplicably opened) make the haunting specific and claustrophobic. The narrator's 'wild, incoherent fantasies' and his sense that he must 'doubt my own reality' show the supernatural attacking reason. Structure: the supernatural escalates from sound (the cry) to presence (the landing) to doubt (reality); it is never confirmed, keeping the reader uncertain; the final image of the cry carried on the wind returns to the opening's storm, leaving the haunting unresolved. Marking notes: AO2 rewards analysis of how language and structure create effects; naming a device without explaining its effect earns little. Levels 3-5 expect comment on both language and structure. Brief, well-chosen quotations are better than long ones.