Question 1
30 marksRemind yourself of 'The Story of an Hour' by Kate Chopin in the Pearson Edexcel International GCSE English Anthology.
How does the writer present the idea of freedom in 'The Story of an Hour'?
In your answer, you should write about:
- what freedom means to Mrs Mallard
- how the idea of freedom develops through the story
- the use of language and structure.
You should refer closely to the text to support your answer. You may include brief quotations.
Model answer
Chopin presents freedom as the most powerful desire in Mrs Mallard's life, something she has not even known she wanted until the news of her husband's death unexpectedly offers it to her.
At first, freedom is presented through setting rather than statement. Alone in her room, Mrs Mallard faces 'the open window', and beyond it the trees are 'all aquiver with the new spring life'. The window symbolises possibility, opening her private world to the outside, and spring suggests a new beginning. The 'patches of blue sky' showing through clouds 'piled one above the other' could symbolise freedom glimpsed through a life that has been weighed down. By placing these images before she understands her own feelings, Chopin lets the setting announce what her mind has not yet admitted.
Freedom then arrives as something with a will of its own. It is 'approaching to possess her', and she strives to 'beat it back'. The irony of being possessed by freedom suggests how deeply she has been taught to resist such feelings; a respectable widow of the 1890s was supposed to grieve, not rejoice. When she gives in, her whispered 'free, free, free!' is short and breathless, and the triple repetition shows her almost tasting the word. Later it grows into the exclamation 'Free! Body and soul free!', and the phrase 'body and soul' presents freedom as total, physical as well as spiritual.
Chopin makes clear what freedom means. It is not escape from cruelty, for her husband had 'never looked save with love upon her'. It is freedom from any 'powerful will bending hers'. The narrator widens the idea to all marriages, in which 'men and women' believe they may impose their will on 'a fellow-creature', and insists that 'A kind intention or a cruel intention' makes the act 'no less a crime'. Abstract, formal vocabulary such as 'illumination' and 'self-assertion' gives her thoughts the weight of a philosophical discovery. Even love counts for little: the exclamation 'What did it matter!' brushes it aside, because self-assertion is 'the strongest impulse of her being'.
Freedom is also presented as time. The list 'Spring days, and summer days, and all sorts of days' has a loose, expansive rhythm that mirrors her sense of an open future, and the contrast with her shudder 'only yesterday' at the thought of a long life shows how her marriage made the future feel like a burden. The metaphor of drinking in 'a very elixir of life' through the window suggests that freedom is life itself.
Finally, the structure shows how fragile this freedom is. It lasts less than an hour. She descends 'like a goddess of Victory', but one short paragraph - 'But Richards was too late.' - reverses everything when her husband returns. Her death suggests that, for a married woman in her world, freedom could be imagined but not lived. The doctors' explanation, 'the joy that kills', is bitterly ironic: it was not joy but the loss of freedom that killed her.
Explanation
The best answers explain what freedom means for Mrs Mallard - freedom from another person's will, not from a cruel husband - and show how the idea grows from an unnamed feeling into an open declaration. They analyse the window and spring imagery, the repeated exclamations and the formal vocabulary of self-assertion, and link the brief duration of her freedom to the ending. Weaker answers simply say she was 'happy to be free' or treat Brently as a villain, which the text does not support.
Mark scheme
-
12 marks
Levels of response (12 marks). AO1 (understanding and interpretation).
Level 1 (1-3 marks): Basic selection of information and ideas; limited use of quotations or textual references; limited understanding, likely shown through retelling or paraphrase.
Level 2 (4-6 marks): Some selection of valid information and ideas; some use of valid quotations or references; some valid interpretation showing a developing understanding.
Level 3 (7-9 marks): Clear and relevant selection of information, ideas and perspectives; clear and relevant use of supporting quotations and references; relevant interpretation showing a clear understanding.
Level 4 (10-12 marks): Detailed and persuasive selection of information, ideas and perspectives; discriminating use of supporting quotations and references; perceptive interpretation showing a convincing understanding.
0 marks: no rewardable material.Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid points): Freedom is something Mrs Mallard has lacked in her marriage even though her husband was kind; for her it means living for herself, with no other person's will 'bending hers'. The narrator widens the idea: in marriage 'men and women' believe they have a right to impose their will on a 'fellow-creature', and Mrs Mallard sees this as wrong whether the intention is kind or cruel. Freedom is linked to the self: 'self-assertion' is the strongest impulse of her being, more important than love, which she calls 'the unsolved mystery'. Freedom also means time and a future: 'all sorts of days that would be her own'; she now prays for a long life. It is both physical and spiritual: 'Body and soul free!'. Freedom arrives unbidden and she first resists it, suggesting that society has taught her such feelings are forbidden; the narrator raises the suggestion that her joy is 'monstrous', though she does not stop to ask and dismisses it as trivial. The others assume she is ill with grief while she is privately rejoicing. Freedom is brief: it lasts less than an hour and ends when Brently returns; her death suggests that for a married woman of the 1890s freedom could be imagined but hardly lived, or could come only through death. Valid interpretations: Chopin criticises marriage as an institution rather than an individual husband; freedom may be an illusion; she dies when freedom is taken from her. Marking notes: AO1 rewards understanding and interpretation of the text in relation to the question focus, supported by apt references. A response that mainly retells the story stays in Level 1 or low Level 2. Accept references and quotations from the anthology text, and accurate paraphrase.
-
18 marks
Levels of response (18 marks). AO2 (analysis of language and structure).
Level 1 (1-3 marks): Limited identification of language and/or structural devices; limited selection of references or examples; basic, simple comment on effects.
Level 2 (4-6 marks): Some identification of language and/or structural devices; some accurate references or examples; some developing comment on effects.
Level 3 (7-10 marks): Clear and relevant selection of language and structural devices; relevant, generally appropriate references and examples; clear explanation of the effects of language and structure.
Level 4 (11-14 marks): Thorough and confident selection of language and structural devices; confident and detailed use of references and examples; detailed exploration of the effects of language and structure.
Level 5 (15-18 marks): Subtle and discriminating selection of language and structural devices; discriminating and assured use of references and examples; perceptive analysis of the effects of language and structure.
0 marks: no rewardable material.Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid points): The 'open window' is a symbol of freedom and possibility, contrasted with the closed door that keeps the others out. Spring imagery ('aquiver with the new spring life', 'patches of blue sky' through clouds 'piled one above the other') suggests new beginnings and freedom glimpsed through oppression. Freedom is personified as a presence 'approaching to possess her', an irony since she is possessed by liberty. The repetition and exclamation of 'free, free, free!' grow into 'Free! Body and soul free!'; the phrase 'body and soul' suggests totality. Abstract, elevated nouns ('self-assertion', 'illumination') give her thoughts philosophical weight. Free indirect style and exclamations ('What did it matter!') show her dismissing love. The balanced phrase 'A kind intention or a cruel intention' equates kindness and cruelty, and the noun 'crime' is shocking. The repetitive list 'Spring days, and summer days, and all sorts of days' has an expansive rhythm that mirrors an open future. The metaphor 'a very elixir of life' presents freedom as life itself. Structure: freedom arrives at the centre of the story after a slow build-up; the triumphant descent 'like a goddess of Victory' is undercut by the one-line paragraph 'But Richards was too late.'; the heart trouble mentioned in the first sentence becomes the means of her death; the final irony, 'the joy that kills', shows that others never understood what freedom meant to her. Marking notes: AO2 rewards analysis of how language and structure create effects; naming a device without explaining its effect earns little. Levels 3-5 expect comment on both language and structure. Brief, well-chosen quotations are better than long ones.