Question 1
30 marksRemind yourself of 'Disabled' by Wilfred Owen in the Pearson Edexcel International GCSE English Anthology.
How does the poet present the contrast between the young man's past and his present in 'Disabled'?
In your answer, you should write about:
- his life before he joined the army
- his life now
- the use of language and structure.
You should refer closely to the text to support your answer. You may include brief quotations.
Model answer
Owen builds the whole poem on a painful contrast between what the young man was and what he has become, and he moves between the two so often that the reader feels the shock of the change again and again.
His present life is presented as cold, colourless and passive. In the opening stanza he simply 'sat' and 'shivered', 'waiting for dark'. His 'ghastly suit of grey' suggests a uniform of the half-dead, and the fragmented description 'Legless, sewn short at elbow' reduces him to his injuries. Even the happy sounds of the park reach him only as 'Voices of boys', heard from a distance.
The second stanza swings back to his past with the phrase 'About this time', as if the time of evening itself triggers the memory. Back then 'Town used to swing so gay' and 'glow-lamps budded in the light blue trees'. The light, the colour and the verb 'budded' suggest springtime, youth and possibility, the opposite of the grey dusk of the present. Girls 'glanced lovelier as the air grew dim', so darkness once meant romance rather than loneliness. The single word 'Now' then wrenches us back: he will 'never feel again how slim / Girls' waists are'. The enjambment across the line ending stretches out the thing he has lost, and the simile 'like some queer disease' shows that the same girls now touch him as if he were infected.
The third stanza makes the contrast even sharper by compressing time. An artist admired his face 'last year'; 'Now, he is old'. The short, blunt clause shows how quickly war has aged him. Owen also contrasts two kinds of blood. Before the war 'he liked a blood-smear down his leg' after football, a sign of toughness that earned him admiration. In war his blood 'spurted from his thigh' and he 'Poured it down shell-holes till the veins ran dry'. Blood that was once a badge of pride is now a sign of his life draining away.
The contrast in public attention is just as bitter. After matches he was 'carried shoulder-high', and he left for war 'with drums and cheers', but when he returned 'Some cheered him home, but not as crowds cheer Goal'. The capitalised 'Goal' makes football glory sound grander than the welcome given to a wounded soldier. Only 'a solemn man' thanks him, and this stanza is just three lines long, as if his return is barely worth recording.
Owen also contrasts his freedom then and now. In the past he made choices: 'He asked to join'. Now things are done to him: he will 'do what things the rules consider wise' and 'take whatever pity they may dole', and he must wait for others to 'put him into bed'. The repeated 'And' at the start of these lines gives a flat, dreary rhythm that mirrors his empty future.
By moving back and forth between memory and reality, Owen makes the reader experience the young man's loss as he does: every bright memory ends by returning him to the cold, dark present.
Explanation
The best answers do more than list differences: they analyse how Owen builds the contrast, through time markers such as 'Now', parallel images (the football 'blood-smear' against the war wound) and the repeated motif of cheering. They comment on structure, such as the alternation of memory and present and the shrinking three-line homecoming stanza. Weaker answers describe the past and the present separately without linking them, or retell the story without analysing language.
Mark scheme
-
12 marks
Levels of response (12 marks). AO1 (understanding and interpretation).
Select and interpret information, ideas and perspectives about the contrast between the young man's past and his present.
Level 1 (1-3 marks): Basic selection of information and ideas; limited use of quotations or textual references; limited understanding, likely shown through retelling or paraphrase.
Level 2 (4-6 marks): Some selection of valid information and ideas; some use of valid quotations or references; some valid interpretation showing a developing understanding.
Level 3 (7-9 marks): Clear and relevant selection of information, ideas and perspectives; clear and relevant use of supporting quotations and references; relevant interpretation showing a clear understanding.
Level 4 (10-12 marks): Detailed and persuasive selection of information, ideas and perspectives; discriminating use of supporting quotations and references; perceptive interpretation showing a convincing understanding.
0 marks: no rewardable material.Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid points): Past: a lively town where 'Town used to swing so gay'; girls were attractive and attracted to him; he was handsome (an artist was 'silly for his face'); he was a sporting hero 'carried shoulder-high', proud of 'a blood-smear down his leg'; carefree and sociable, drinking 'a peg' after football; he chose to join and was sent off 'with drums and cheers'. Present: in a wheelchair, 'Legless, sewn short at elbow'; alone in the park at dusk; women avoid him and look past him to 'the strong men that were whole'; he is 'old'; he is dependent on others and must obey 'the rules'; his homecoming was muted ('not as crowds cheer Goal'); his future is 'a few sick years in Institutes'. The speed of the change: 'last year' against 'Now, he is old'. The contrast in agency: in the past he acted ('He asked to join'); now things are done to him ('put him into bed'). Perceptive responses note the irony that the qualities which led him to join (vanity, love of admiration, his body) are exactly what he has lost, and that the contrast exposes the cost of war. Marking notes: mark AO1 and AO2 separately, each by best fit. A response that mainly retells the poem stays in Level 1 or 2. Misreadings of the poem limit the level. Context is credited only where it supports interpretation of the poem.
-
18 marks
Levels of response (18 marks). AO2 (analysis of language and structure).
Analyse how the poet uses language and structure to present the contrast between the young man's past and his present.
Level 1 (1-3 marks): Limited identification of language and/or structural devices; limited selection of textual references; basic, simple comment on effects.
Level 2 (4-6 marks): Some identification of language and/or structural devices; some accurate textual references; some developing comment on effects.
Level 3 (7-10 marks): Clear and relevant selection of language and structural devices; relevant and generally appropriate textual references; clear explanation of effects.
Level 4 (11-14 marks): Thorough and confident selection of language and structural devices; confident and detailed textual references; detailed exploration of effects.
Level 5 (15-18 marks): Subtle and discriminating selection of language and structural devices; discriminating and assured use of textual references; perceptive analysis of effects.
0 marks: no rewardable material.Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid points): Time markers and tense shifts ('About this time', 'In the old times', 'Now', 'last year') structure the contrast; active, lively verbs of the past ('swing', 'glanced', 'liked', 'carried') against static ones in the present ('sat', 'shivered', 'waiting'); light and colour of the past ('glow-lamps', 'light blue trees') against 'suit of grey', 'dark' and 'lost his colour'; the verb 'budded' suggests spring and youth; parallel blood images: 'blood-smear down his leg' (pride after football) against 'leap of purple spurted from his thigh' (devastating wound); the motif of cheering: 'carried shoulder-high', 'drums and cheers', 'Some cheered him home, but not as crowds cheer Goal'; capitalised 'Goal'; enjambment 'how slim / Girls' waists are'; abrupt caesura 'Now, he is old'; simile 'like some queer disease'; structure: alternation between stanzas of memory and the present; the long, crowded enlistment stanzas against the three-line homecoming stanza; anaphora of 'And' in both the list of army attractions and the dreary list of his future; the ending returns to the present and to night. Marking notes: naming a device without explaining its effect gains little credit. From Level 3 upwards a response should comment on both language and structure. Quotations should be brief and precise; long copied passages are not discriminating.