Question 1
3 marksRead Source A and answer the question.
Baucis and Philemon have fed the two disguised gods, who now reveal who they are.
Source A: Ovid, Metamorphoses 8.689-691, 696-702 and 706-712 (translated, with omissions)
'We are gods,' they said, 'and your wicked neighbours will pay the penalty they deserve; but you will be granted freedom from this disaster.' ... The old couple turned their eyes and saw everything else drowned in a marsh, with only their own house still standing. While they marvelled at this and wept for the fate of their people, that old cottage, small even for its two owners, was turned into a temple: columns took the place of its forked wooden posts, the straw thatch grew yellow until the roof looked golden, the doors were carved and the ground was covered with marble. ... Philemon told the gods the choice he shared with Baucis: 'We ask to be your priests and to guard your shrine; and since we have spent our years in harmony, let the same hour take us both, so that I never see my wife's tomb, and am never buried by her.' Their prayer was fulfilled: they looked after the temple for as long as they lived.
Using Source A, explain how the gods punished the neighbours and rewarded Baucis and Philemon. Make three points, at least one about each.
Model answer
The neighbours were punished: everything around was drowned in a marsh. Baucis and Philemon were spared, since their house was the only one left standing, and their cottage was turned into a temple with columns, a golden roof and a marble floor. Their wish was also granted: they became the gods' priests and guarded the temple for the rest of their lives.
Explanation
The question asks for both the punishment and the reward, so an answer about only one of them is capped at 2 marks, as OCR's SAM mark scheme insists on 'At least one point from each part of the question' (Q3). Each point must be a different fact from Source A; the golden roof, columns and marble are all part of one point (the temple). The story shows a belief that the gods reward the pious and hospitable and punish those who refuse strangers.
Mark scheme
-
3 marks
1 mark for each of the following, max 3, with at least one point from each part: the neighbours' homes / land / everything except the couple's house was drowned in a marsh (1); Baucis and Philemon were spared the disaster / only their house was left standing (1); their cottage was turned into a temple (1); with columns / a golden roof / carved doors / a marble floor (1, for one or more of these details, credited once); they became the gods' priests / the guardians of the temple for the rest of their lives (1); their wish to die at the same time was granted (1).
Max 2 if all the points are about only one of the two parts of the question. 'The neighbours paid the penalty they deserved' and 'they were drowned' are one point: credit once. The points must come from Source A: do not credit details from elsewhere in the story, such as the couple being turned into trees, as one of the three points (compare OCR 2024 Q7 ER: 'reference to a feature not visible in the source ... could not gain credit').