Read Source A and answer the question.
In Cicero's dialogue On the Nature of the Gods, the Stoic Balbus uses examples from Roman history to argue that the gods exist and must be respected. Before a battle a Roman commander took the auspices: if the sacred chickens ate eagerly, it was a good sign.
Source A: Cicero, On the Nature of the Gods 2.7-8 (translated, with omissions)
Will we not be moved by the recklessness of Publius Claudius in the First Punic War? Even making fun of the gods, when the sacred chickens were let out of their cage and would not feed, he ordered them to be plunged into the water so that they might drink, since they refused to eat. That joke brought many tears to him, and a great disaster to the Roman people, when his fleet was defeated. And his colleague Junius, in the same war - did he not lose his fleet in a storm, after disobeying the auspices? So Claudius was condemned by the people, and Junius took his own life. Coelius writes that Gaius Flaminius, having neglected religion, fell at Trasimene, with a great wound to the state. From the deaths of these men we can understand that our state was made great under the command of those who obeyed religion. And if we are willing to compare our ways with those of foreign peoples, we shall find that in other things we are equal or even inferior, but in religion, that is, in the worship of the gods, we are far superior.
How does Balbus try to persuade his listeners that respect for religion made Rome great? In your answer you should include discussion of the writer's use of language.
Model answer
Balbus begins with rhetorical questions: 'Will we not be moved by the recklessness of Publius Claudius ...?' and 'did he not lose his fleet in a storm ...?' These questions challenge his listeners and suggest that only a fool could disagree, so they are pushed towards accepting his argument before he states it.
He uses real, named Romans whose disasters his audience knew. Claudius is shown 'making fun of the gods', and Balbus repeats his joke that the chickens should be plunged into the water 'so that they might drink, since they refused to eat'. Repeating the flippant joke makes his disrespect vivid. Balbus then contrasts the 'joke' with the 'many tears' and the 'great disaster' it caused, so the punishment seems to fit the mockery, and the phrase 'to him, and ... to the Roman people' shows that one man's impiety harms the whole state.
The consequences are stated bluntly: Claudius 'was condemned by the people' and Junius 'took his own life'. Flaminius' defeat is called 'a great wound to the state', a metaphor that pictures Rome as a body injured by neglect of religion. After three examples Balbus draws his conclusion as if it were proved: 'From the deaths of these men we can understand that our state was made great under the command of those who obeyed religion.'
Finally he compares Rome with foreign peoples. He first admits that the Romans are 'equal or even inferior' in other things; this modest concession makes his final claim, that 'in religion ... we are far superior', more believable, and ends the passage on a note of national pride.
Explanation
A strong point quotes Balbus's words and explains how they persuade, for example how the repeated joke makes Claudius's disrespect vivid. OCR's 2023 report warned that 'even eloquent responses fell short if they gave no textual examples', and the 2022 report, on linguistic points not supported by reference to the source, that 'Answers such as "there is a tricolon" ... will not gain access to the higher levels'. Technical terms are not needed, and punctuation alone is never a strong point.