Read Source A and answer the question.
Source A: Cicero, On the Laws 2.58 (translated, with omissions)
'A dead person,' says the law in the Twelve Tables, 'shall not be buried or burned in the city.' I think this is perhaps because of the danger of fire. ... But just as the law forbids burial in the city, so the college of pontiffs decreed that it is not right for a tomb to be made on public land.
Imagine you are a wealthy citizen of Pompeii in the 1st century AD, planning your own tomb. Explain what you would include in your tomb and its inscription, and what you would ask your family to do after your death, so that your spirit is at peace and you are remembered.
In your answer:
- you should include references to a range of ancient sources;
- you may make use of the source printed;
- you may wish to include reference to particular tombs at Pompeii and to festivals for the dead.
Model answer
First I would choose the right place. Source A says that the law of the Twelve Tables forbids anyone to be 'buried or burned in the city', so my tomb must stand outside the walls. I would build it beside the road leading out of the Herculaneum Gate, where every traveller going to and from Pompeii would pass it, because a tomb that is seen is a tomb that is remembered. Since the pontiffs ruled that a tomb should not be on public land, I would buy my own plot, unless, like the priestess Mamia, I had served the town so well that the council granted me a place by decree.
Next I would design the tomb. Like Naevoleia Tyche, I would build a tall marble monument shaped like an altar, because the dead are honoured as divine spirits and receive offerings at it. Inside the base there would be a chamber where my urn could rest safely, since I would not want my ashes disturbed; the girl Mus begged the passer-by, 'do not harm my bones'. I would also have a pipe built into the grave, like those found at the Nocera Gate cemetery, so that my family could pour wine down to my ashes on festival days.
My inscription would begin D M, 'to the spirits of the dead', and give my name, my age and my offices. If the council had honoured me, I would record it and have it carved, as Naevoleia Tyche had her husband's bisellium carved on the side of their tomb, so that my status would be remembered. I would add my portrait and speak directly to the reader, like Mus: 'I beg you, stranger', so that passers-by would stop, read my name and think of me. Like Naevoleia, I would include my freedmen and freedwomen in the tomb, because they would have a reason to look after it after my children were gone.
Then I would tell my family their duties. They must cremate me properly and bury my ashes, because Virgil's Sibyl says that the unburied must wander for a hundred years before they can cross the river. Every February, at the Parentalia, they must bring the small gifts Ovid describes, 'a tile hung with garlands', grain, salt, 'bread soaked soft in unmixed wine' and violets, with prayers, just as Aeneas brought gifts to his father's Genius. Ovid warns that when the Parentalia was once neglected the ghosts 'howled through the streets', so I would want them never to forget. They should also bring roses at the Rosalia and hold a meal at my tomb on the anniversary of my death.
In this way my spirit would be cared for with offerings and prayers, so that it rested in peace and did not become an angry ghost, and my name, my honours and my generosity would be remembered by everyone who passed along the road.
Explanation
Imagined-role questions are marked like any 12-mark essay: OCR's 2023 report said the demands, 'despite the creative instruction, were in line with previous years'. Each choice should be justified by evidence and linked to the two aims in the question, peace for the spirit and remembrance; OCR's 2025 mark scheme gave only partial credit to 'References to death and burial rituals only'. Level 4 needs material beyond Source A, such as particular Pompeian tombs, Ovid's Fasti or epitaphs.