Read Source A and answer the question.
Source A: Vegetius, Epitoma rei militaris 1.10 (translated, with omissions)
Every recruit, without exception, should learn to swim in the summer months. For rivers are not always crossed by bridges, and an army is often forced to swim, both when it retreats and when it pursues. Streams often flood after sudden rain or snow, and men who cannot swim are in danger not only from the enemy but from the water itself. ... It is very useful to train to swim not only the infantry but also the cavalry, and the horses themselves, and the camp servants, whom they call galiarii, so that nothing happens to them through lack of skill when the need arises.
Imagine that you are the commander of a newly built auxiliary fort in northern Britain in the second century AD. Explain how you will organise the fort and train your soldiers so that your unit is ready to fight, and your men stay fit and loyal.
In your answer:
- you should include references to a range of ancient sources;
- you may make use of the source printed;
- you may wish to include reference to the plan of a typical Roman fort, the barrack block at Chesters, the rest of Vegetius' account of training and the Vindolanda tablets.
Model answer
As commander, my first task is to make the fort safe, because soldiers who feel secure fight better. Following the plan of a typical Roman fort, I will surround it with a ditch, an earth rampart and a wall, with towers at every corner and beside each of the four gates. Straight streets, the via principalis, via praetoria and via decumana, will run to the gates, so my men can reach any part of the wall in moments if we are attacked.
At the centre I will build the headquarters, with a shrine for our standards. Soldiers treated the standards as sacred, and Caesar tells how the eagle-bearer of the Tenth Legion shamed his comrades into jumping into the sea by warning them not to 'betray the eagle to the enemy' (Gallic War 4.25). Honouring the standards every day will keep my men loyal to Rome and to me. Beside the headquarters I will build granaries with raised floors, like those at Housesteads, so that our grain stays dry and we have a reserve if we are besieged.
My barracks will follow the pattern of Chesters: long blocks of paired rooms, each shared by a contubernium of messmates, with the officer's quarters at the end. Men who eat and sleep together fight for one another, and the Vindolanda letter that greets a soldier's 'messmates' (Tab. Vindol. 346) shows how close these groups were.
Training will follow Vegetius. Recruits will learn the military step until they can march 20 miles in five summer hours, so that our column never breaks up on the march. They will run, so that they can charge with force and seize good positions before the enemy, and jump, so that ditches will not stop them. In summer they will learn to swim, because, as Vegetius says in Source A, rivers are not always bridged and sudden rain or snow makes them flood, a real danger in northern Britain; my cavalrymen and even their horses will learn too. Every morning and afternoon they will fight the six-foot posts with wicker shields and clubs of double weight, so that real weapons feel light in battle.
To keep the men fit, I will copy the stone latrines of Housesteads, flushed with stored rainwater, and build a bath-house like the one at Chesters. I will keep a daily report like the Vindolanda strength report (Tab. Vindol. 154), which separates the sick, the wounded and those with eye inflammation from the men fit for duty, and a hospital will care for them. Warm clothing matters too: a Vindolanda letter lists socks and underpants, probably sent to a soldier (Tab. Vindol. 346).
Loyalty also depends on rewards. Good soldiers will see a path to promotion, like the optio at Chester who was 'awaiting promotion to centurion' (RIB 544), and their pay and savings will be safe in the headquarters strongroom, so that, like Rufus Sita, a horseman with 22 years of service, they can leave property to their heirs and be properly commemorated (RIB 121).
Of all these measures, Vegetius' training matters most, because a well-drilled unit can survive even when its defences fail; but training alone is not enough unless the men are healthy, well supplied and proud of their unit.
Explanation
Level 4 needs about five strong points, each using precise evidence from a range of sources, including some beyond Source A (fort plans, Vegetius, Housesteads or Chesters, the Vindolanda tablets, tombstones) and explaining how each measure makes the unit ready to fight, fit or loyal. In the similar 2023 villa question OCR's mark scheme said "Expect appreciation of 'successful'", and its examiners' report said that candidates "who just listed design features ... without bringing out their benefit, did not score full marks". Modern or invented ideas without ancient evidence earn only partial credit.