Study Source A and answer the question.
Source A: a description of Hadrian's Wall
Hadrian's Wall was begun in about AD 122, on the orders of the Emperor Hadrian. It ran for 80 Roman miles (73 modern miles) across northern Britain, from Wallsend on the River Tyne to Bowness-on-Solway, with a ditch along most of its northern side. There was a small fort, called a milecastle, at every Roman mile, with two turrets between each pair of milecastles. Within a few years about fifteen larger forts, among them Chesters and Housesteads, were added to the line.
'The roads were the most important thing the Romans built in Britain.'
How far do you agree with this statement?
In your answer:
- you should include references to a range of ancient sources;
- you may make limited use of the source printed;
- you may wish to include reference to the map of Roman Britain, the forts, villas, and the baths at Bath.
Model answer
I largely agree with the statement, because without the roads the Romans could not have conquered, held or changed Britain; but some other buildings did more to make the Britons Roman.
The roads were essential to the conquest. The Fosse Way was in use by about AD 47, only four years after the invasion, running from Exeter to Lincoln along the edge of the territory the Romans then controlled. The map of Roman Britain shows roads linking the legionary fortresses at York, Chester and Caerleon, and Dere Street running north from York to Hadrian's Wall and beyond. Caesar shows what Britain was like without such roads: in 54 BC Cassivellaunus hid his charioteers in woods beside the tracks and attacked the Roman cavalry along 'every road and path' (Gallic War 5.19). Straight, well-built roads let the legions move quickly and safely.
The roads also held the province together. The Vindolanda strength report (Tab. Vindol. 154) shows soldiers of one cohort spread across Britain, 337 at Corbridge and a centurion in London, which only worked if men could travel. Traders used the roads too: Octavius wanted hides and a wagon at Catterick handed over to him (Tab. Vindol. 343). Milestones such as RIB 2265, 'From Kanovium 8 miles', carried the emperor's name across the province, and the roads lasted so well that the A5 still follows Watling Street.
On the other hand, Hadrian's Wall (Source A) was arguably just as important. Begun in about AD 122, it ran for 80 Roman miles from Wallsend to Bowness-on-Solway, with a milecastle every mile, two turrets between each pair and forts such as Housesteads and Chesters. It marked and protected the frontier of the province in a way roads alone could not.
Other buildings did more to change how the Britons lived. Tacitus says that Agricola encouraged the Britons to build 'temples, forums and houses', and that they drifted into enjoying 'colonnades and baths and the elegance of dinner parties' (Agricola 21). At Bath the great bath complex and temple of Sulis Minerva drew visitors to a Roman way of bathing and worship. Villas such as North Leigh, with its courtyard, bath suites and at least nineteen mosaic floors, show wealthy Britons living like Romans.
However, these buildings depended on the roads. North Leigh stood only about 850 metres from Akeman Street, which could take its produce to market, and Bath lay on the Fosse Way. Without roads, the Wall could not have been supplied and the towns and villas could not have traded.
In conclusion, the roads were the most important thing the Romans built, not because they were the most impressive, but because the conquest, the frontier, the towns and the villas all depended on them.
Explanation
Level 4 needs about five strong points from a range of sources, with a counter-argument and a reasoned conclusion. The best answers use precise evidence for the roads (the Fosse Way, Dere Street, milestones, the Vindolanda tablets) and weigh them against Hadrian's Wall, the forts, Bath, the villas and Tacitus' account of Romanisation. Listing buildings without arguing which mattered most stays at Level 2 or 3.