Study Source A.
Source A: a description of the Roman palace at Fishbourne, near Chichester, West Sussex
Fishbourne was built in about AD 75, only about thirty years after the Roman invasion, and is the largest known Roman residence north of the Alps. Four long wings of rooms surround a large formal garden, the earliest garden yet found in Britain. Many of the floors are mosaics, the earliest laid in black and white geometric patterns; a later mosaic shows Cupid riding on a dolphin. The palace was discovered in 1960 by workmen digging a trench for a water main. Some archaeologists think it was built for Togidubnus, a British king who was loyal to Rome.
'Villas in Roman Britain were built mainly to show off the wealth and status of their owners.' How far do you agree with this statement?
In your answer:
- you should include references to a range of ancient sources;
- you may make limited use of Source A;
- you may wish to include reference to other villas you have studied and to Columella's advice on the villa.
Model answer
I agree that the grandest villas were built to impress, but most villas in Roman Britain were first of all the centres of farming estates.
Source A shows a villa built to show off. Fishbourne, built only about thirty years after the invasion, is the largest known Roman residence north of the Alps, with four wings around a formal garden and floors of mosaics. If it was built for Togidubnus, a British king loyal to Rome, it was meant to display both his wealth and his status as Rome's ally.
Later villas show the same wish to impress. North Leigh grew into a great courtyard villa with three bath suites and at least nineteen mosaic floors. At Lullingstone the dining room had a mosaic of Europa and the bull with a Latin couplet joking about Juno and Aeolus, placed where guests reclining on their couches could read it (RIB 2448.6); the owner was showing off his learning as well as his wealth. At Bignor guests saw Ganymede carried off by the eagle and cupids dressed as gladiators. Tacitus says that Agricola encouraged the Britons to build houses and that 'competition for honour took the place of force', so that they drifted towards 'colonnades and baths and elegant dinner parties' (Agricola 21). Building a fine villa was a way to compete for status.
On the other hand, villas were also working farms. Columella divides a villa into three parts: the owner's house, but also the farmhouse and the storehouse, with stalls for oxen, granaries reached by ladders, and quarters for the bailiff and the slaves. At North Leigh, surveys have found further buildings to the south, probably farm buildings, and Lullingstone had a granary more than 24 metres long, one of the largest found at any civilian site in Roman Britain. These buildings were for producing and storing crops, not for show.
Many features were also for comfort. Columella wants rooms that catch the winter sun and baths that are bright in the afternoon; British owners added underfloor heating, which made sense in a cold climate whether or not anyone was watching. The earliest villas were plain: Lockleys in about AD 65 was a simple row of four rooms, a farmhouse rather than a status symbol, and it only gained a corridor and extra rooms later, as its owners grew richer.
Villas were places of religion too: Lullingstone had a room used as a Christian house-church, with wall paintings of figures at prayer, and Chedworth a shrine around its spring.
In conclusion, the statement is true of the grandest houses, such as Fishbourne and North Leigh at its height, where mosaics and baths displayed wealth and Roman culture. But most villas were built mainly to run profitable estates, and their luxury grew only as that profit allowed.
Explanation
Level 4 needs about five strong points from a range of villas and texts, including material not printed on the paper, with a counter-argument and a conclusion. The best answers weigh display (mosaics, baths, size, Tacitus' 'competition for honour') against the working estate (Columella's farmhouse and storehouse, granaries, farm buildings). Listing the features of villas without saying why they were built does not reach the top level.