Question 1
2 marksIn chapter 12 of the Agricola, Tacitus describes the resources of Britain.
Source A: Tacitus, Agricola 12.6-7 (translated)
Britain produces gold and silver and other metals, the prize of victory. The Ocean also produces pearls, but they are dusky and bluish-grey. Some people think that those who gather them lack skill: for in the Red Sea they are torn from the rocks alive and breathing, but in Britain they are collected just as they are washed up. For my part, I would more easily believe that the pearls lack quality than that we lack greed.
Study Source A. What does Source A suggest about Tacitus' attitude to the Romans' wish to win Britain's wealth? Make two points, using Source A.
Model answer
Tacitus calls Britain's metals 'the prize of victory', which suggests that he saw wealth as one of the things Rome won by conquering Britain. He is also sarcastic about Roman greed: he would sooner believe that the pearls lack quality 'than that we lack greed', so he criticises the Romans, himself included, for wanting wealth at any price.
Explanation
The marks are for Tacitus' attitude, shown through his words, not for listing gold, silver and pearls. The last sentence is ironic: the Romans will never be short of greed. This critical streak is worth remembering whenever Tacitus is judged as a source for Rome's actions in Britain.
Mark scheme
-
2 marks
1 mark for each of the following, max 2: he calls the metals 'the prize of victory', suggesting he saw wealth as a reward / reason for conquest; he is critical or sarcastic about Roman greed ('than that we lack greed'); by saying 'we' he admits that Romans in general (himself included) are greedy; he mocks the idea that the gatherers lack skill, suggesting the Romans will never stop wanting pearls whatever their quality; he plays down the value of British pearls ('dusky and bluish-grey'), so the reward was disappointing
Insist on at least one reference to Source A. This course's guidance (adapted from OCR 2025 Q10, not OCR's wording): some indication of how the words show his attitude is required, rather than just a list of Britain's resources; direct quotation is not required.