Read Source A and answer the question.
Source A: Virgil, Aeneid 1.1-7 (translated)
I sing of arms and of the man who first came from the shores of Troy, an exile by fate, to Italy and the shores of Lavinium. He was much tossed about on land and sea by the power of the gods above, because of the unforgetting anger of cruel Juno, and he suffered much in war too, until he could found a city and bring his gods into Latium. From him came the Latin race, the fathers of Alba and the walls of lofty Rome.
Imagine that you are a sculptor in Rome and Augustus has asked you to make a statue group showing the most important moment in the story of Rome's beginnings, from the fall of Troy to the founding of the city. Which moment would you choose? Give reasons for your answer.
In your answer:
- you should include references to a range of ancient sources;
- you may make limited use of the source printed;
- you may wish to include reference to Aeneas' escape from Troy, the she-wolf and the twins, and the founding of the city.
Model answer
I would choose Aeneas carrying his father Anchises and the household gods out of burning Troy, with his son Ascanius beside him. I think this is the most important moment because without it there would be no Rome at all, and because it would suit Augustus better than any other.
First, this moment is the true beginning of the Roman story. Virgil calls Aeneas the man who came 'an exile by fate' and suffered much 'until he could found a city and bring his gods into Latium. From him came the Latin race, the fathers of Alba and the walls of lofty Rome.' Romulus was a descendant of Aeneas through the Alban kings, so the whole line begins with the escape. Ovid also says that 'the fates do not allow the hope of Troy to be overthrown along with its walls', which makes this moment the turning point from Troy's ruin to Rome's future.
Secondly, the scene shows the most Roman quality of all, pietas. Ovid calls Aeneas 'the dutiful man' who chooses his father and the sacred objects as his only plunder 'out of so much wealth', and calls his father 'a burden that deserves reverence'. In Virgil, Aeneas tells Anchises to carry the household gods because it is a sin for him to touch them after the slaughter. A statue of this moment would teach every Roman duty to the gods, to parents and to the future.
Thirdly, it would please Augustus personally. The Julian family claimed descent from Iulus, the son of Aeneas; Livy says that the Julian clan calls Ascanius 'Iulus' as the founder of their name. Julius Caesar had already put Aeneas carrying Anchises on his coins, with Venus on the other side, to advertise his divine ancestry, and Augustus, his adopted son, would want the same message.
The main rival is the she-wolf suckling Romulus and Remus. It is a powerful image of divine protection: Livy says the founding was 'owed to the fates' and that the wolf offered her teats 'so gently'. It was already Rome's symbol, as the Lupercal panel of Augustus' own Ara Pacis shows. However, the twins are helpless babies, and the story leads to Romulus' quarrel with Remus. Livy calls it an 'ugly quarrel' arising from 'the desire to be king', and in his more common version Romulus kills his brother in anger. After years of civil war, Augustus would not want a monument that reminded people of brother killing brother.
The founding of the city itself, with Romulus seeing twelve vultures, shows the gods' approval and gives Rome its name, but it also has Remus' death close behind it, and birds and walls are hard to show in a statue.
In conclusion, I would choose Aeneas' escape from Troy. It is the beginning of the whole story, it shows pietas in a single clear image of three generations, and it honours Augustus' own family without the shadow of fratricide.
Explanation
This personal-response question rewards a clear choice backed by five or more strong points, each with precise evidence (Ovid's 'dutiful man', Virgil's 'bring his gods into Latium', Livy on Iulus and on Remus' death, Caesar's coin, the Ara Pacis). For a similar question ('Imagine that you are the emperor in Rome ...'), OCR's 2024 report looked for 'an argument as to why they as Emperor would choose one venue or another'; here, why one moment rather than another. Description of the statue without reasons, or reasons without evidence, stays in the lower levels.