Question 1
2 marksDescribe one feature of the rivalry between Henry VIII and Francis I.
Model answer
Henry VIII was jealous of Francis I's military success. Soon after becoming king in 1515, Francis won the Battle of Marignano and took Milan, a victory far greater than anything Henry had achieved in France.
Explanation
Full marks need a clear feature of the rivalry backed by a specific detail, such as Marignano, the Field of the Cloth of Gold or the war of 1522-23. A common error is to describe the war of 1512-13, which was fought against Louis XII before Francis became king.
Mark scheme
-
1 mark
A valid feature of the rivalry between Henry VIII and Francis I identified, e.g. it was a personal rivalry for glory and reputation / Henry was jealous of Francis's military success / they competed in displays of magnificence / Henry claimed the French crown / Francis interfered in Scotland / the rivalry led to war in the 1520s
Award one mark for a valid feature identified. The second mark should be awarded for supporting information. e.g. Henry was jealous of Francis's military success (1). Soon after becoming king in 1515, Francis won a great victory at Marignano and took Milan, which Henry had never achieved (1). / It was a personal rivalry (1); in 1515 Henry asked a Venetian envoy whether Francis was as tall and as stout as he was and what his legs were like (1). / They competed in magnificence (1), most famously at the Field of the Cloth of Gold in 1520, where each king tried to outshine the other (1). / The rivalry turned into war (1); England declared war on France in 1522 and an English army marched towards Paris in 1523 (1). Accept other appropriate features and supporting information.
-
1 mark
Supporting information that develops the feature identified, e.g. for personal rivalry: two young kings of similar age who both wanted to be seen as great Renaissance princes; Henry's questions about Francis's height, build and legs in 1515; Henry's promise in 1519 not to shave his beard until he met Francis; for jealousy: the Battle of Marignano (September 1515) and the capture of Milan; for magnificence: the Field of the Cloth of Gold (June 1520) with its temporary palace and tournaments, and the wrestling match in which, according to French accounts, Francis threw Henry; for the French crown: English kings still called themselves kings of France and Henry hoped to win the French throne in the 'Great Enterprise' with Charles V; for Scotland: Francis sent or allowed the Duke of Albany to go to Scotland (1515 and 1521) to stir up trouble for Henry; for war: the Treaty of Bruges (1521), war declared in May 1522, the raids of 1522 and the Duke of Suffolk's march of 1523; after Francis was captured at Pavia (1525), Henry hoped to divide France
The supporting information must develop the feature already identified. Do not credit a second statement of the same feature in other words, or a general comment such as 'they did not like each other'. Do not credit events of the war of 1512-13, which was fought against Louis XII, not Francis I (Francis became king in January 1515), or confusion of Francis I with Charles V.