Question 1
2 marksDescribe one feature of Henry VIII's argument that he had never been lawfully married to Catherine of Aragon.
Model answer
Henry's argument was based on the Bible. The Book of Leviticus says that a man who marries his brother's wife will be childless, and Henry had married Catherine, the widow of his brother Arthur, so he saw the deaths of his sons as God's punishment.
Explanation
A strong answer names one part of Henry's case, such as Leviticus or the claim that the papal dispensation was invalid, and develops it with precise detail. Students sometimes credit Henry with Catherine's arguments, such as her claim that her first marriage was never consummated, which earns no marks.
Mark scheme
-
1 mark
A valid feature of Henry's argument identified, e.g. it was based on the Book of Leviticus / he claimed the papal dispensation for the marriage was invalid / he saw the deaths of his sons as God's punishment / he claimed Catherine's marriage to Arthur had been consummated / he said his conscience was troubled
Award one mark for a valid feature identified. The second mark should be awarded for supporting information. e.g. Henry's argument was based on the Bible (1). The Book of Leviticus forbids a man to marry his brother's wife and says such a couple will be childless, and Catherine had been the wife of his brother Arthur (1). / He argued that the papal dispensation was invalid (1). He claimed that Pope Julius II, who had allowed the marriage in 1503, had no power to set aside God's law, or that the dispensation contained errors (1). / He saw the deaths of his sons as a punishment from God (1): all his sons by Catherine had died, which he believed matched the curse of childlessness in Leviticus (1). / He claimed his conscience was troubled (1), and in a speech at Bridewell in November 1528 he said that doubts had been raised about whether Mary was his lawful daughter (1). Accept other appropriate features and supporting information.
-
1 mark
Supporting information that develops the feature identified, e.g. for Leviticus: Leviticus 20:21 (and 18:16) forbids marrying a brother's wife and says the couple will be childless; Henry interpreted 'childless' as 'without a son'; for the dispensation: granted by Pope Julius II in 1503; Henry argued that no pope could dispense with divine law, or that the bull was flawed because the reasons it gave were untrue (for example, that the marriage was needed to keep the peace, although Henry himself, as a boy, had made a formal protest against the marriage contract in 1505); for God's punishment: Prince Henry died in 1511 and other sons were stillborn or died at birth, while Mary was the only survivor; for consummation: his lawyers claimed that Arthur had boasted the morning after his wedding that the marriage had been consummated, which would mean Catherine was truly his brother's wife; for conscience: Henry said a French envoy, the Bishop of Tarbes, had questioned Mary's legitimacy in 1527, and that he wanted the truth settled for the sake of his soul and the realm
The supporting information must develop the feature already identified. Do not credit a second statement of the same feature in other words, or a general comment such as 'he thought the marriage was wrong'. Do not credit the passage in Deuteronomy, which commands a man to marry his dead brother's widow: it was used by Catherine's supporters against Henry, not by Henry. Do not credit Catherine's own claim that her marriage to Arthur was never consummated as part of Henry's argument. Do not credit later events such as Cranmer's judgment of 1533. Accept 'divorce' for annulment, as contemporaries used both words, but Henry's case was that the marriage had never been valid.