Question 1
2 marksDescribe one feature of the demands made by the Lincolnshire rebels in October 1536.
Model answer
The demands attacked the King's advisers. The articles agreed at Lincoln asked Henry to take noblemen as his councillors and to hand over or banish Thomas Cromwell, Sir Richard Rich and the visitors of the monasteries, Legh and Layton.
Explanation
The first mark is for one clear feature of the demands, such as who drew them up, the call to stop closing abbeys or the attack on Cromwell; the second is for a precise detail of what was asked or how the King answered. Do not confuse the Lincolnshire articles of October 1536 with the Pontefract Articles drawn up in Yorkshire in December.
Mark scheme
-
1 mark
A valid feature of the Lincolnshire rebels' demands identified, e.g. they were drawn up as articles by gentlemen / they asked for no taxes except in time of war / they asked for the Statute of Uses to be repealed / they defended the Church's liberties and opposed first fruits and tenths / they asked that no more abbeys be closed / they attacked the 'heretic' bishops / they asked the King to remove Cromwell and other low-born councillors / they asked for a pardon / they claimed to be the King's loyal subjects / they were sent to the King, who rejected them
Award one mark for a valid feature identified. The second mark should be awarded for supporting information. e.g. The demands were drawn up by gentlemen (1). At Horncastle on 4 October 1536 the gentlemen wrote down the commons' articles and added a demand for the repeal of the Statute of Uses, a law the commons had not heard of until it was explained to them (1). / They asked that no more abbeys be closed (1); the articles agreed at Lincoln asked that no more monasteries should be suppressed, at a time when royal commissioners were closing the smaller houses in the county (1). / They attacked the King's advisers (1); they asked Henry to take noblemen as his councillors and to hand over or banish Cromwell, Sir Richard Rich and the visitors of the monasteries, Legh and Layton (1). / The King rejected them (1); Henry's answer called the rebels 'the rude commons of one shire', told them it was not for them to choose a prince's councillors and said the monasteries had been closed by Act of Parliament (1). Accept other appropriate features and supporting information.
-
1 mark
Supporting information that develops the feature identified, e.g. for who drew them up: the gentlemen at Horncastle (4 October) and in the Chapter House of Lincoln Cathedral, among them the sheriff Edward Dymmoke and other gentlemen taken by the commons; for taxation: no taxes except in time of war, the subsidy granted in 1534 still being collected, the release of the fifteenth; for the Statute of Uses: a law of 1536 that landowners disliked because it limited how they could provide for younger sons and daughters; for the Church: its ancient liberties kept, tenths and first fruits not to be taken by the government; for the abbeys: no more to be suppressed; for the heretic bishops: Cranmer, Latimer and Longland, the Bishop of Lincoln, to be deprived and punished; for councillors: noblemen to be the King's councillors, Cromwell, Rich, Legh and Layton handed over or banished; for the pardon: all who had taken part to be pardoned; for loyalty: the rebels called themselves the King's true subjects; for the King's answer: the demands rejected one by one, Lincolnshire called 'one of the most brute and beastly' shires of the realm
The supporting information must develop the feature already identified. Do not credit a second statement of the same feature in other words, or a general comment such as 'they wanted things to change'. Do not credit demands made only in Yorkshire, such as the Pontefract Articles' call for the Pope's authority to be restored or for Princess Mary to be made legitimate, or answers that say the Lincolnshire rebels demanded Henry VIII's removal. Exact wording and the number of articles are not required.