Question 1
2 marksDescribe one feature of the Duke of Norfolk's opposition to Cromwell.
Model answer
Norfolk led the religious conservatives against Cromwell. In May 1539 he put six questions on religion before the House of Lords, which led to the Act of Six Articles, a serious setback for Cromwell's religious reforms.
Explanation
The first mark is for a clear aspect of Norfolk's opposition, such as his religious conservatism or his part in the arrest, and the second for a specific detail such as the Six Articles or the events of 10 June 1540. Make sure the answer is about Norfolk and Cromwell, not Norfolk's earlier quarrel with Wolsey.
Mark scheme
-
1 mark
A valid feature of Norfolk's opposition identified, e.g. he resented the power of a man of humble birth / he led the religious conservatives at court / he used his niece, Catherine Howard / he worked with Stephen Gardiner / he took part in Cromwell's arrest / he opposed Cromwell's alliance with the German Protestants
Award one mark for a valid feature identified. The second mark should be awarded for supporting information. e.g. Norfolk resented Cromwell as a low-born rival (1). He was England's leading nobleman and Lord Treasurer, but Cromwell, a tradesman's son, had more influence with the King, and in 1536 Cromwell had helped to keep him away from court (1). / Norfolk led the religious conservatives (1); in May 1539 he put the six questions on religion before the House of Lords, which led to the Act of Six Articles, a defeat for Cromwell's reforms (1). / He took a personal part in Cromwell's arrest (1); at the Council meeting on 10 June 1540 he tore the badge of the Order of the Garter from Cromwell's neck (1). / His niece, Catherine Howard, caught the King's eye in 1540 (1), which gave the Howard family influence over Henry and made him keen to end the Cleves marriage that Cromwell had arranged (1). Accept other appropriate features and supporting information.
-
1 mark
Supporting information that develops the feature identified, e.g. for resentment: Norfolk's rank (third Duke of Norfolk, Lord Treasurer, Earl Marshal) against Cromwell's humble Putney background; Cromwell keeping him from court in 1536; for religion: the six questions in the Lords (16 May 1539) and the Act of Six Articles; opposition to the alliance with the German Protestants; for Catherine Howard: his niece, in Anne of Cleves's household, married to Henry on 28 July 1540; for Gardiner: the two worked together as leaders of the conservative faction; for the arrest: 10 June 1540, tearing off the Garter badge; later questioning Cromwell in the Tower about the Cleves marriage; for foreign policy: his mission to Francis I in February 1540
The supporting information must develop the feature already identified. Do not credit a second statement of the same feature in other words, or a general comment such as 'Norfolk hated him'. Do not credit answers that confuse Norfolk with the Duke of Suffolk (Charles Brandon), that describe Norfolk as a Protestant or as Cromwell's ally in 1539-40, or that say Norfolk put Cromwell on trial (Cromwell was condemned by an Act of Attainder without trial). Norfolk's opposition to Wolsey belongs to an earlier topic and does not answer this question.