Question 1
2 marksDescribe one feature of the Act in Conditional Restraint of Annates (1532).
Model answer
The Act in Conditional Restraint of Annates threatened to stop new bishops paying annates, their first year's income, to Rome. It was conditional, because it would only come into force if Henry confirmed it, so he could use it to put pressure on Pope Clement VII to grant the annulment.
Explanation
The strongest answers identify what the Act did or why it was 'conditional', then add a precise detail such as the definition of annates or the claim that £160,000 had gone to Rome. Many answers simply say it 'stopped money going to the Pope', which misses the point that Henry kept the decision in his own hands as a bargaining weapon.
Mark scheme
-
1 mark
A valid feature of the Act identified, e.g. it threatened to stop payments of annates (a new bishop's first year's income) to Rome / it was conditional: the king could decide whether and when it came into force / it was designed to put pressure on Pope Clement VII / it allowed bishops to be consecrated in England if the Pope refused to issue bulls / it claimed that huge sums had been sent to Rome / it met resistance in Parliament / Henry confirmed it in July 1533
Award one mark for a valid feature identified. The second mark should be awarded for supporting information. e.g. The Act stopped new bishops paying annates to Rome (1). Annates were the first year's income of a bishopric, which had to be paid before the Pope issued the bulls confirming a new bishop (1). / The Act was conditional (1); it would only come into force if the king confirmed it by letters patent, so Henry could use it as a bargaining weapon (1). / It was meant to put pressure on Pope Clement VII (1); it threatened a valuable part of the Pope's income unless he helped Henry over the annulment (1). / It allowed bishops to be consecrated without the Pope (1); if Rome refused or delayed the bulls, the king's nominee could be consecrated by the archbishop in England (1). / It claimed that England had lost huge sums (1); the Act said that about £160,000 had gone to Rome in annates since the reign of Henry VII (1). / Henry confirmed it in July 1533 (1), after Archbishop Cranmer had declared his first marriage invalid (1). Accept other appropriate features and supporting information.
-
1 mark
Supporting information that develops the feature identified, e.g. for annates: also called first fruits, paid by archbishops and bishops for their bulls; for the condition: the king was to declare by letters patent, before Easter 1533 or the next Parliament, whether the Act should take effect; for pressure: the Act allowed the king to settle the matter with the Pope by a 'friendly' agreement instead, and Henry let Rome know that Parliament had left the decision to him; for consecration: an archbishop by two bishops chosen by the king, a bishop by the archbishop of the province; for the sums: the Act's claim of 800,000 ducats, about £160,000, since the second year of Henry VII; payment for bulls limited to 5 per cent of a see's yearly value; for resistance: the votes were taken in the king's presence and the Commons had to divide; for confirmation: letters patent of 9 July 1533; for later: a further Act in 1534 ended the payment of annates to Rome completely
The supporting information must develop the feature already identified. Do not credit a general comment such as 'it stopped money going to the Pope' with no detail. Do not confuse annates with Peter's Pence, tithes or the clergy's fine of 1531 (the Pardon of the Clergy). Do not credit claims that the Act of 1532 itself gave the annates to the king (first fruits were transferred to the Crown by the First Fruits and Tenths Act of 1534) or that it ended all payments to Rome at once. Accept 'about £160,000' or the Act's '800,000 ducats'.