Question 1
2 marksDescribe one feature of the general pardon that Henry VIII granted in 1509.
Model answer
In April 1509, at the start of his reign, Henry granted a general pardon that was wider than the one his father had granted just before he died. However, about eighty people were excluded from it, including his father's hated financial agents, Empson and Dudley.
Explanation
A full-mark answer identifies one feature of the pardon, such as its wide scope, the people excluded from it or its promise of justice, and supports it with a precise detail. Stronger answers often show its purpose: to mark a fresh start after Henry VII's harsh financial methods. Do not claim that Empson and Dudley were pardoned: they were among those excluded.
Mark scheme
-
1 mark
A valid feature of Henry VIII's general pardon of 1509 identified, e.g. it was one of the first acts of his reign / it was wider than the pardon his father had granted / it pardoned offences committed before the new reign began / some people were excluded from it / it promised that people who had been wronged could seek justice / it promised to end the harsh enforcement of old laws by informers and officials / it was meant to make the new king popular
Award one mark for a valid feature identified. The second mark should be awarded for supporting information. e.g. It was wider than the pardon Henry VII had granted a few days before he died (1). Henry VIII extended it to almost all offences, except debts (1). / Some people were excluded from the pardon (1). About eighty people were named as exceptions, including Empson and Dudley and members of the Yorkist de la Pole family (1). / It promised justice to people who had been wronged (1). Anyone who had suffered could seek a remedy at law, and royal officers were ordered to act justly (1). / It was meant to win support for the new king (1). It showed that the new reign would be more generous than his father's, whose harsh financial methods had made him feared (1). Accept other appropriate features and supporting information.
-
1 mark
Supporting information that develops the feature identified, e.g. for timing: proclaimed in April 1509, within days of Henry VII's death on 21 April and dated 23 April, before the coronation; for its scope: Henry VII had pardoned offences committed before 10 April, and Henry VIII's wider pardon covered all offences except debt; anyone could obtain it from the Lord Chancellor; for exclusions: a list dated 30 April named about eighty exceptions, including Empson and Dudley, the de la Pole brothers and the Marquess of Dorset (who was later pardoned); for justice: those wronged could sue at law, and the commissions of sheriffs and justices were renewed; for informers: the king promised to end the harsh use of old laws by informers known as promoters and by customs officers, and some promoters were punished; for popularity: the exclusion of Empson and Dudley pleased the many people who had suffered from their methods
The supporting information must develop the feature already identified. Do not credit a second statement of the same feature in other words, or general comments such as 'it was kind'. Accept 'April 1509' or 'at the start of his reign' for the date. Do not credit claims that Empson and Dudley were pardoned, or that the pardon cancelled all debts owed to the Crown: debts were excluded. Do not confuse it with the Act of Pardon for the clergy (1531).