Question 1
2 marksDescribe one feature of Thomas More's resignation as Lord Chancellor in 1532.
Model answer
More resigned as Lord Chancellor on 16 May 1532, the day after the Submission of the Clergy. The clergy had just accepted that they could not make Church laws without the king's consent, a change that More could not support.
Explanation
Full marks need one clear feature, such as the timing of the resignation or the reason More gave, supported by a precise detail such as the link with the Submission of the Clergy. Watch the chronology: More resigned in 1532, two years before the Acts of Succession and Supremacy, so do not say he resigned because of them.
Mark scheme
-
1 mark
A valid feature of More's resignation identified, e.g. it came the day after the Submission of the Clergy / More officially gave ill health as his reason / it showed his disapproval of the attack on the Church and of the king's plans to end his marriage / he gave the Great Seal back to the king / it cost him most of his income / he avoided open opposition and withdrew into private life / he was replaced by Thomas Audley
Award one mark for a valid feature identified. The second mark should be awarded for supporting information. e.g. More resigned the day after the Submission of the Clergy (1). On 15 May 1532 the clergy agreed that they could not make Church laws without the king's approval, and More resigned on 16 May (1). / More officially resigned because of ill health (1). He told his friend Erasmus that poor health was the reason, though he had been unhappy with the king's policies (1). / It showed his disapproval of the attack on the Church (1). More believed the Church's independence and the Pope's authority came from God and he would not support Henry's plans to end his marriage to Catherine of Aragon (1). / He handed back the Great Seal (1). He returned it to the king in the garden of York Place, Wolsey's former London house (1). / It cost him most of his income (1). He had to sell his plate and live on about £100 a year from his own lands (1). / He withdrew quietly instead of leading opposition (1). He lived privately at Chelsea, writing books against Protestant reformers such as Tyndale, and did not speak against the king in public (1). / He was replaced by Thomas Audley (1). Audley was made Lord Keeper of the Great Seal in May 1532 and Lord Chancellor in January 1533 (1). Accept other appropriate features and supporting information.
-
1 mark
Supporting information that develops the feature identified, e.g. for timing: 16 May 1532, the day after the clergy's Submission (15 May 1532); for the reason given: ill health, as he told Erasmus; for disapproval: he had opposed the government's attacks on the Church in the council, would not support the annulment of Henry's marriage to Catherine, and later refused to attend Anne Boleyn's coronation (June 1533); for the Great Seal: handed back in the garden at York Place; for money: sold his plate and lived on about £100 a year; for withdrawal: writing against Tyndale and Frith at Chelsea, avoiding public criticism of the king; for his successor: Thomas Audley; for the length of his time in office: Lord Chancellor from October 1529, so only about two and a half years
The supporting information must develop the feature already identified. Do not credit a general comment such as 'he was unhappy'. Do not credit claims that More was dismissed or arrested in 1532 (he resigned and remained free until April 1534), that he resigned because of the Act of Supremacy or the oath of succession (both 1534), or that Cromwell replaced him as Lord Chancellor (Cromwell never held that office). Accept answers that say More felt he could no longer serve, or was under pressure, if supported.