Question 1
2 marksDescribe one feature of Cromwell's personality.
Model answer
Cromwell was charming and sociable. The imperial ambassador Chapuys described him as a good speaker who was generous with his goods and gracious in his words, and he entertained on a grand scale at his house at Austin Friars in London.
Explanation
Full marks need one quality of Cromwell's character backed by a specific example, such as his loyalty to Wolsey in 1529 or his hard work on Wolsey's colleges. Listing several adjectives without evidence, or describing Wolsey's personality instead, earns at most one mark.
Mark scheme
-
1 mark
A valid feature of Cromwell's personality identified, e.g. he was extremely hard-working and efficient / he was highly intelligent with a remarkable memory / he was practical and businesslike / he was charming, witty and good company / he was generous and hospitable / he was ambitious / he could be ruthless and harsh / he was loyal to his master / he was interested in religious reform
Award one mark for a valid feature identified. The second mark should be awarded for supporting information. e.g. Cromwell was extremely hard-working (1). For Wolsey he ran the closure of about 29 small monasteries, surveying their property, drawing up the deeds and keeping the accounts for the new colleges (1). / He was loyal (1); when Wolsey fell in 1529 he stayed with him at Esher and defended him in the House of Commons (1). / He was charming and good company (1); the imperial ambassador Chapuys described him as a good talker, generous with his goods and gracious in his words (1). / He was ambitious (1); at Wolsey's fall he told George Cavendish that he would ride to court and 'either make or mar' (1). / He could be ruthless (1); monks were turned out of the houses closed for Wolsey's colleges, and complaints about the conduct of Cromwell and his fellow agent John Allen reached the king (1). Accept other appropriate features and supporting information.
-
1 mark
Supporting information that develops the feature identified, e.g. for hard work: the monastery closures and colleges (1525-29), his lists of 'remembrances', managing Wolsey's legal business while running his own practice; for intelligence and memory: self-taught, several languages (Italian, French, Latin), success as a lawyer and merchant; for practicality: his letter mocking the Parliament of 1523, which 'left where we began'; for charm: Chapuys's description, his friendships with merchants such as John Creke and Stephen Vaughan, his entertaining at his house at Austin Friars; for ambition: 'make or mar' (1 November 1529), seeking a seat in Parliament in 1529, his rapid collection of royal offices (1532-34); for ruthlessness: monks turned out of their houses, the complaints of 1527, his later treatment of opponents such as Elizabeth Barton (1534); for loyalty: weeping at Esher, defending Wolsey against the bill of articles, giving £5 towards the wages of Wolsey's servants; for religious reform: friendship with the reformer Miles Coverdale, who praised his zeal for godly study, and his later support for an English Bible
The supporting information must develop the feature already identified. Do not credit a list of adjectives with no example (e.g. 'he was clever and ambitious'), or a second statement of the same feature. Credit positive or negative features, as long as each is supported with evidence from Cromwell's life. Historians disagree about when Cromwell's own religious views changed, so credit interest in religious reform only when it is supported with evidence. Do not credit features of Wolsey's or Henry VIII's personality.