Question 1
2 marksDescribe one feature of Anne Boleyn's miscarriage in January 1536.
Model answer
Anne miscarried on 29 January 1536, the day of Catherine of Aragon's funeral. According to the imperial ambassador, Chapuys, the baby appeared to be a boy, so Henry lost his hope of a son by Anne.
Explanation
Full marks need one clear feature, such as the timing of the miscarriage or the report that the baby was a boy, supported by a precise detail such as Catherine's funeral or Henry's fall at the lists five days earlier. Answers that drift into a general account of Anne's fall, without describing the miscarriage itself, may earn only one mark.
Mark scheme
-
1 mark
A valid feature of the miscarriage identified, e.g. it happened on the day of Catherine of Aragon's funeral / the baby was reported to be a boy / Anne blamed the shock of the news of Henry's fall at a tournament / Henry was very distressed / it ended Anne's hopes of securing her position with a son / it followed earlier pregnancies that had not produced a son
Award one mark for a valid feature identified. The second mark should be awarded for supporting information. e.g. The miscarriage happened on 29 January 1536 (1), the day Catherine of Aragon was buried at Peterborough (1). / The baby was reported to be a boy (1); the imperial ambassador Chapuys wrote that it seemed to be a male child of about three and a half months (1). / Anne blamed the shock of hearing about Henry's accident (1); five days earlier Henry had fallen heavily from his horse at a tournament at Greenwich, and her uncle, the Duke of Norfolk, brought her the news (1). / It ended Anne's hopes of a son (1); she had written that 'if I have a son, as I hope shortly to have', she knew what would happen to Mary (1). Accept other appropriate features and supporting information.
-
1 mark
Supporting information that develops the feature identified, e.g. for the date: 29 January 1536, about three weeks after Catherine's death on 7 January; for the boy: Chapuys's report of a male child of about three and a half months; for the accident: on 24 January 1536 Henry and his horse fell together at the lists; Chapuys said he was not hurt, while another report said he was unconscious for two hours (accept either); for Henry's reaction: Chapuys reported that Henry showed great distress, and had already been heard to say in confidence that he had been tricked into the marriage by witchcraft and that God had not allowed them to have male children; for her hopes: she had hoped a son would secure her position, and Henry's interest in Jane Seymour was already noticed at court; for earlier pregnancies: Elizabeth (born 7 September 1533) and a pregnancy in 1534 that did not produce a living child
The supporting information must develop the feature already identified. Do not credit a second statement of the same feature in other words, or a general comment such as 'it was very sad'. Do not credit claims, as fact, that the baby was deformed: one historian (Retha Warnicke) has suggested this, but there is no contemporary evidence for it; credit it only if it is clearly presented as a historian's theory. Do not confuse the miscarriage with the birth of Elizabeth (1533). Answers should describe the event factually; do not credit statements that blame Anne for the loss of the baby.