'Guru Gobind Singh did more than any other Guru to establish equality.'
Evaluate this statement.
In your answer you should:
- refer to Sikh teaching
- give reasoned arguments to support this statement
- give reasoned arguments to support a different point of view
- reach a justified conclusion.
[12 marks]
[+ 3 SPaG marks]
Model answer
There are strong reasons to agree that Guru Gobind Singh did more than any other Guru to establish equality. At Vaisakhi in 1699 he founded the Khalsa, turning the earlier Gurus' teaching into a community with clear rules. The Panj Pyare came from different castes and regions, yet they all drank amrit from one bowl and, in Sikh tradition, all the men took the name Singh and women the name Kaur, removing caste surnames. Women were initiated on the same terms as men and wore the same five Ks. He then asked the Panj Pyare to initiate him, showing that even the Guru was not above the Khalsa. In the Akal Ustat he taught that the whole human race should be recognised as one, and he praised Bhai Kanhaiya for giving water to wounded enemy soldiers. Finally, by making the Guru Granth Sahib the Guru, he placed all Sikhs equally under the scripture.
However, many would argue that Guru Nanak did more, because he laid the foundations on which everything else was built. His declaration that 'there is no Hindu, there is no Muslim', his choice of Bhai Lalo's plain bread over Malik Bhago's feast, the first langar at Kartarpur and his teachings in the Guru Granth Sahib on caste (GGS 349) and women (GGS 473) all came first. Other Gurus also made major contributions: Guru Angad and Mata Khivi developed the langar; Guru Amar Das made even the Emperor Akbar eat in the langar, condemned sati (GGS 787) and gave women leadership roles; Guru Arjan included the words of bhagats from different castes and faiths in the Adi Granth; and Guru Tegh Bahadur gave his life for the religious freedom of Hindus.
Many Sikhs would also question the statement itself, because they believe all ten Gurus shared the same divine light (jot). On this view, equality was established by one continuous mission, not by any single Guru.
In conclusion, I think the statement is only partly true. Guru Gobind Singh did the most to build equality into the structure of the Sikh community through the Khalsa. However, his work depended completely on Guru Nanak's teaching and on the practices developed by the Gurus in between, so it is more accurate to see equality as the achievement of all ten Gurus together.
Explanation
Strong answers compare Guru Gobind Singh's contribution with specific examples from other Gurus, such as Guru Nanak and Guru Amar Das, rather than just describing the Khalsa. Including the Sikh belief that the Gurus shared one divine light shows deeper understanding and can support a well-justified conclusion. Make sure every example is attributed to the correct Guru.