'The Mool Mantra tells Sikhs everything they need to know about God.'
Evaluate this statement.
In your answer you should:
- refer to Sikh teaching
- give reasoned arguments to support this statement
- give reasoned arguments to support a different point of view
- reach a justified conclusion.
[12 marks]
[+ 3 SPaG marks]
Model answer
Some Sikhs would agree that the Mool Mantra tells them everything they need to know about God. In just a few phrases on the first page of the Guru Granth Sahib, it states that God is one (Ik Onkar), the eternal truth (Sat Naam), the Creator (Karta Purakh), without fear or hate, timeless, unborn and self-existent. Guru Nanak placed it at the start of his teaching, and the rest of the scripture develops these same themes rather than adding a different picture of God. It also ends with Gur Prasad, 'by the Guru's grace', which tells Sikhs the most important practical truth: that God is known through grace. Because it is short, every Sikh, even a child, can learn the essentials.
However, there are strong reasons to disagree. The Gurus taught that God can never be completely described. In the Japji Sahib Guru Nanak says that even knowing God, he cannot describe God in words (GGS 2), and elsewhere he says that God's limits cannot be known (GGS 469). If that is true, no text, however important, can tell Sikhs 'everything'. The Mool Mantra also leaves out much that Sikhs need: it does not explain in detail how God is sargun, within creation, and nirgun, beyond it (GGS 290), nor does it describe God's hukam or God's love for devotees. It does not explain how to come closer to God through nam japna, sewa and the virtues. Other texts give different emphases too: the Jaap Sahib in the Dasam Granth praises God with countless names, and the Ardas begins by remembering God as Bhagauti, the divine power. Many Sikhs would add that God is known through experience and meditation, not only through words.
In conclusion, I disagree with the statement. The Mool Mantra tells Sikhs the most important things about God and is the foundation for all other teaching, but by Sikh teaching itself God is beyond full description, and the Mool Mantra points to grace and experience rather than claiming to be complete. It is everything Sikhs need to begin, not everything they need to know.
Explanation
High-level answers use the Mool Mantra's content as evidence for the statement and then challenge the word 'everything' with Sikh teaching that God cannot be fully described. Apply sources, such as GGS 2 or GGS 469, to the argument rather than just quoting them. A justified conclusion should explain which argument is stronger and why.