'Meditating on God's Name is the most effective way to remove haumai.'
Evaluate this statement.
In your answer you should:
- refer to Sikh teaching
- give reasoned arguments to support this statement
- give reasoned arguments to support a different point of view
- reach a justified conclusion.
[12 marks]
[+ 3 SPaG marks]
Model answer
Many Sikhs would agree that meditating on God's Name is the most effective way to remove haumai. Guru Amar Das taught that ego and the Name are opposed and cannot live in the same place (GGS 560): when the mind is filled with God, there is simply no room left for the self-centred 'I'. Nam japna is the first of the three duties Guru Nanak taught, and many Sikhs rise in the early morning (amrit vela) to meditate on 'Waheguru' for this reason. Meditation works at the root of the problem, the mind itself, whereas other practices may only change outward behaviour. It also helps a person to become aware of God's hukam, and the Japji Sahib teaches that someone who understands hukam no longer speaks in ego (pauri 2).
On the other hand, many Sikhs would argue that sewa is just as effective, or more so, because it confronts pride in practice. Washing dishes in the langar or cleaning the sangat's shoes makes a person act humbly, whatever their status, and the Sukhmani Sahib teaches that one who serves selflessly attains the Lord (GGS 286). Meditation can even become a source of spiritual pride if someone meditates in order to appear holy, whereas humble physical service is harder to boast about. Others would point to the Guru's word: Guru Angad taught that the cure for ego is found when, by God's grace, a person acts on the Guru's Shabad (GGS 466), so studying and living by gurbani is the key. The company of the sangat also helps. Above all, Sikhs believe that haumai is finally removed by God's grace (nadar) rather than by any technique.
In conclusion, I partly agree. Nam japna is probably the most important single practice, because it changes the mind from which all ego comes, and the Gurus put it first. However, it is most effective when combined with sewa and the sangat, which put that inner change into practice and keep it honest. For most Sikhs, meditation, service and grace work together, so it would be misleading to say that any one of them removes haumai on its own.
Explanation
Top answers compare nam japna with other ways of overcoming haumai, such as sewa, gurbani and the sangat, and support each with Sikh teaching like GGS 560, GGS 286 or GGS 466. Including the role of God's grace shows deeper understanding. A justified conclusion should decide what 'most effective' means rather than simply listing practices.