'Every Sikh should visit the Golden Temple at least once in their life.'
Evaluate this statement.
In your answer you should:
- refer to Sikh teaching
- give reasoned arguments to support this statement
- give reasoned arguments to support a different point of view
- reach a justified conclusion.
Model answer
Many Sikhs would agree that every Sikh should visit the Golden Temple at least once. The Harmandir Sahib was built by Guru Arjan, who installed the Adi Granth there in 1604, and it stands beside the Akal Takht, so no other gurdwara has the same history. In the daily Ardas, Sikhs pray to be granted the sight of Amritsar and a bath in its sarovar, so visiting fulfils a hope that Sikhs express every day. Guru Arjan himself wrote that bathing in the pool of Ram Das washes away sins (Guru Granth Sahib 625). A visit can also be life-changing: pilgrims hear kirtan from early morning until night, do sewa in the langar and see people of every religion and caste eating together. This can be especially important for young British Sikhs, who may come home with a much stronger sense of their faith and identity.
However, other Sikhs would say that 'should' is too strong. Unlike the Hajj in Islam, Sikhism has no compulsory pilgrimage. Guru Nanak taught in the Japji Sahib that bathing at holy places means nothing without God's grace, and that the true place of pilgrimage is the Name of God within (Guru Granth Sahib 687). God is present everywhere, so any gurdwara with the Guru Granth Sahib is the Guru's house, and a Sikh who never travels to Amritsar but lives by nam japna, kirat karni and vand chhakna is not a lesser Sikh. Travel to India is expensive, and some Sikhs argue the money could do more good if given to help others. Others cannot travel because of age, illness or disability, and it would be wrong to make them feel they have failed in their faith.
In conclusion, I think visiting the Golden Temple is a very valuable experience that many Sikhs hope for, and the Ardas shows how much it means to the community. But I disagree that every Sikh should visit, because the Gurus taught that the real pilgrimage is inward and they did not make it a duty. It is best seen as a blessing to hope for, not a requirement.
Explanation
The highest levels weigh the value of a visit (history, Ardas, sewa, equality) against Guru Nanak's teaching on inner pilgrimage, with Sikh sources applied to the word 'should'. A justified conclusion should follow from the arguments, for example distinguishing a valuable experience from a duty. Claiming that Sikhs must make a pilgrimage, as Muslims must make the Hajj, is a factual error.