'Sikhs can learn more about God from the natural world than from the Guru Granth Sahib.'
Evaluate this statement.
In your answer you should:
- refer to Sikh teaching
- give reasoned arguments to support this statement
- give reasoned arguments to support a different point of view
- reach a justified conclusion.
[12 marks]
[+ 3 SPaG marks]
Model answer
Some Sikhs might agree with this statement. Sikhs believe God is sargun, present in and through the whole of creation. Guru Nanak wrote that God's creative power 'is pervading everywhere' (GGS 469) and that God's light is in all beings (GGS 13). Nature is therefore like an open book about God, available to everyone, including people who cannot read Gurmukhi. It shows God's power, order and beauty in a way that anyone can experience directly. The Gurus themselves pointed to nature: in the Aarti the sky is a plate and the sun and moon are lamps worshipping God (GGS 13), and Guru Nanak called air the Guru, water the father and earth the great mother (GGS 8). Modern science, revealing a universe of countless galaxies, even fits Guru Nanak's description of hundreds of thousands of skies (GGS 5).
However, most Sikhs would disagree. They believe God is known through Gur Prasad, the Guru's grace, and the Guru today is the Guru Granth Sahib, the living word of God. Nature can show that God is powerful, but it cannot teach God's Name, God's will or how to achieve mukti; only the Guru's word explains nam japna, sewa and the virtues. God is also nirgun, beyond creation, and Guru Nanak says God's limits cannot be known (GGS 469), so nature can only ever show part of God. Nature also contains floods, disease and suffering, which could give a confusing picture of God, and attachment to the material world (maya) can distract people from God. Guru Tegh Bahadur taught that there is no need to search for God in the forest, because God is within (GGS 684).
In conclusion, I disagree with the statement. Nature is a real and beautiful revelation of God's sargun aspect, but it cannot show God's nirgun aspect or teach Sikhs how to live and reach God. The Guru Granth Sahib actually teaches Sikhs how to see God in nature in the first place, so the scripture must come first, with the natural world as a powerful support.
Explanation
High-level answers weigh nature as a revelation of God's sargun aspect against the role of the Guru Granth Sahib as the living Guru, using specific references. The strongest answers notice that the scripture itself points Sikhs to nature, and use this in the conclusion. Avoid general comments about nature being beautiful without linking them to Sikh teaching about God.