'All Sikhs should use Singh or Kaur as their surname.'
Evaluate this statement.
In your answer you should:
- refer to Sikh teaching
- give reasoned arguments to support this statement
- give reasoned arguments to support a different point of view
- reach a justified conclusion.
Model answer
Many Sikhs agree that all Sikhs should use Singh or Kaur as their surname. In Punjab family names often showed a person's caste, and the Gurus taught that caste has no place in the eyes of God: Guru Nanak said people should recognise God's light in everyone and not ask about caste (Guru Granth Sahib 349). Using only Singh or Kaur hides caste and shows that all Sikhs belong to one family, just as the Panj Pyare, who came from different castes, became one Khalsa in 1699. The Sikh Rahit Maryada says that a boy's name must have Singh and a girl's Kaur. Keeping a caste-linked family name can keep prejudice alive, for example when families look for marriage partners from the same caste, so dropping it is a clear way to put the Gurus' teaching into practice.
However, other Sikhs argue that this is too strict. The Rahit Maryada requires Singh or Kaur as part of the name, but it does not forbid a family surname as well, so a Sikh whose name is Harpreet Kaur followed by a family surname is still following it. In Britain there are practical reasons for using family names: official forms expect a surname, and family names help schools, doctors and employers tell apart the many people called Singh or Kaur. For many families the name is about heritage, not caste pride. Some point out that removing a name does not remove prejudice. Kabir asked, if the whole world came from one light, who is good and who is bad (Guru Granth Sahib 1349), and equality is shown by how people treat others in the langar and in daily life. Saying all Sikhs 'should' do this may also be unfair to sahajdhari Sikhs, who are following the Sikh path gradually.
In conclusion, I think the statement expresses the Gurus' ideal, and using Singh or Kaur alone is a powerful way to reject caste. However, I do not think every Sikh must do so, because the Rahit Maryada only requires the names as part of a Sikh's name, and true equality depends on attitudes and actions. Sikhs who keep a family name should make sure it never becomes a reason to treat others as inferior.
Explanation
High-level answers weigh the Gurus' rejection of caste and the Rahit Maryada against practical and family reasons for surnames in Britain, applying Sikh sources to the word 'should'. A precise point that lifts answers is that the Rahit Maryada requires Singh or Kaur in the name but does not forbid a family surname. Avoid assuming all family names are caste names or that all Sikhs use them for the same reasons.