'Maya (illusion) is the greatest barrier to mukti.'
Evaluate this statement.
In your answer you should:
- refer to Sikh teaching
- give reasoned arguments to support this statement
- give reasoned arguments to support a different point of view
- reach a justified conclusion.
[12 marks]
[+ 3 SPaG marks]
Model answer
Some Sikhs would agree that maya is the greatest barrier to mukti. Maya is the illusion that the material world is all that matters, and it makes people forget that God is the only lasting reality. Guru Amar Das warned that attachment to maya is so enticing that it has consumed the whole world without even having teeth (GGS 643). Maya can also be seen as the source of the other barriers: if a person believes that money, pleasure and status matter most, they will be drawn into greed (lobh), lust (kaam) and attachment (moh). In modern Britain, where advertising constantly suggests that happiness comes from buying things, maya may be especially powerful, which supports the statement.
However, many Sikhs would argue that haumai (ego or self-centredness) is an even greater barrier. It is the self-centred 'I' that is deceived by maya and that wants more for itself. Guru Angad called haumai a chronic disease (GGS 466), and Guru Amar Das taught that ego and God's Name cannot live in the same place (GGS 560). On this view, maya only has power over a person because of their ego, so haumai is the root problem. Others would say the five thieves are the most dangerous in daily life because their effects are immediate: anger can destroy a relationship in a moment and lust can break a marriage. Another view is that the barriers are so closely linked that it makes no sense to call one the greatest; different people struggle most with different barriers, so for one Sikh pride may be the hardest to overcome, while for another it is greed. Sikhs also believe that mukti comes through God's grace (nadar), so no barrier is too great for God to remove.
In conclusion, I do not think maya is the greatest barrier on its own. It is extremely powerful, but it works through a person's ego: a humble, God-centred person can live surrounded by wealth, like a lotus on water, without being deceived. Haumai is therefore the deeper barrier, and maya is better seen as its most dangerous partner.
Explanation
To reach the top level, weigh maya against other barriers such as haumai or the five thieves, using Sikh teaching like GGS 643 or GGS 466 to support each side. The conclusion should follow from the arguments, for example by deciding which barrier is the root of the others. A common weakness is to describe all the barriers in turn without ever judging whether maya is the 'greatest'.