'Sikhs should be more concerned about this life than about what happens after death.'
Evaluate this statement.
In your answer you should:
- refer to Sikh teaching
- give reasoned arguments to support this statement
- give reasoned arguments to support a different point of view
- reach a justified conclusion.
[12 marks]
[+ 3 SPaG marks]
Model answer
There are strong reasons to agree that Sikhs should focus on this life. Sikh teaching says that mukti can be reached while still alive: Guru Arjan describes the jivan mukt, liberated while living, as someone who loves God's will (GGS 275). Guru Arjan also wrote that the human body is your turn to meet God (GGS 12), so the opportunity is now, not after death. Sikhism is a householder faith: the Gurus taught Sikhs to meditate on God's Name, earn an honest living, share with others and do sewa in everyday life, rather than withdrawing from the world to prepare for death. Many Sikhs also see heaven and hell as temporary states within the cycle of rebirth (GGS 278), not final rewards, and Guru Nanak criticised empty rituals for the dead, as in the well-known story of his visit to Haridwar.
However, others would argue that Sikhs must also be concerned about what happens after death. Belief in karma means that actions in this life shape the soul's future: the Japji Sahib says you harvest what you plant (GGS 4). Guru Arjan warned that those who forget their Creator come and go in rebirth again and again (GGS 50), and the ultimate aim, mukti, includes the soul's release from rebirth and its union with God beyond this life. At funerals Sikhs say the Ardas, praying that the soul will merge with God, which shows that they care deeply about life after death.
In conclusion, I agree with the statement, but only partly. Sikh teaching clearly places the emphasis on this life, because it is the precious opportunity to meet God and because liberation can begin now. However, Sikhs cannot ignore what happens after death, since karma links this life to the next. The best Sikh view is that being properly concerned about this life is the way to take care of the soul's future, so the two concerns point in the same direction.
Explanation
Top answers weigh teaching on jivan mukti and the value of human life against karma and the aim of release from rebirth, using specific references. A strong conclusion shows how the two concerns relate rather than simply choosing one. Answers that only describe beliefs about rebirth, without evaluating the statement, stay in the lower levels.