'Sikhs should spend more time developing virtues than praying.'
Evaluate this statement.
In your answer you should:
- refer to Sikh teaching
- give reasoned arguments to support this statement
- give reasoned arguments to support a different point of view
- reach a justified conclusion.
[12 marks]
[+ 3 SPaG marks]
Model answer
Some Sikhs would agree with this statement. Guru Nanak taught in the Japji Sahib, 'vin gun keete bhagat na hoi': without virtue there can be no true devotion (GGS 4), which suggests that prayer is worthless unless it comes from a virtuous life. He also taught that truth is higher than everything, but higher still is truthful living (GGS 62): what matters most is living faith out in practice. The Gurus criticised people who performed long rituals while cheating or oppressing others, as in the story of Guru Nanak refusing the rich Malik Bhago's feast and eating with the honest carpenter Bhai Lalo. Virtues such as justice, patience and humility also benefit families and communities directly, so time spent developing them, through sewa and honest work, could seem more valuable than time spent in prayer.
On the other hand, many Sikhs would strongly disagree. Nam japna, remembering God's Name, is the first of the three key duties, and Guru Arjan wrote that nothing else will help a person: they should join the holy congregation and meditate on the Name (GGS 12). Guru Nanak said that even millions of religious rituals cannot equal God's Name (GGS 62). Sikhs also believe that virtue is a gift of God's grace, since God blesses the unworthy with virtue (GGS 2), and prayer is how a person opens themselves to that grace. Prayer weakens haumai, the ego from which pride, anger and greed grow, so it is actually the source of the virtues. This is why amritdhari Sikhs commit to the daily Nitnem.
In conclusion, I disagree with the statement because it wrongly treats prayer and virtue as rivals. Sikh teaching sees them as two sides of one life: prayer without virtue is empty, but virtue without prayer lacks its source in God's grace. The Gurus taught that Sikhs should remember God's Name while working and serving, so the ideal is not to spend more time on one than the other, but to let prayer and virtue fill the whole day together.
Explanation
Strong answers use teachings that seem to support each side, such as GGS 4 for virtue and GGS 12 for meditation, and then evaluate how they fit together. A conclusion that explains why the two cannot be separated, or why one has priority, shows high-level evaluation. Avoid one-sided answers that only praise prayer or only praise good deeds.