Question 1
3 marksRavi is asked to find the exact value of \(\displaystyle\int_3^4 \dfrac{5}{(x - 2)(x + 3)}\,dx\). His working is shown below.
Line 1: \(\dfrac{5}{(x - 2)(x + 3)} = \dfrac{1}{x - 2} - \dfrac{1}{x + 3}\)
Line 2: \(\displaystyle\int_3^4 \dfrac{5}{(x - 2)(x + 3)}\,dx = \left[\ln(x - 2) - \ln(x + 3)\right]_3^4\)
Line 3: \(= (\ln 2 - \ln 7) - (\ln 1 - \ln 6)\)
Line 4: \(= \ln 2 - \ln 7 - \ln 6\)
Line 5: \(= \ln\dfrac{1}{21}\)
Identify the line in which Ravi first makes an error and explain the error.
Find the correct exact value of the integral, giving your answer as a single logarithm.
Model answer
The error is in Line 4. Line 3 is correct, but \(-(\ln 1 - \ln 6) = -\ln 1 + \ln 6 = +\ln 6\), whereas Ravi wrote \(-\ln 6\).
Correct value: \((\ln 2 - \ln 7) - (0 - \ln 6) = \ln 2 - \ln 7 + \ln 6\)
\(= \ln\dfrac{2 \times 6}{7} = \ln\dfrac{12}{7}\)
Explanation
Lines 1 to 3 are correct: the partial fractions, the integral and the substituted limits. Subtracting the value at the lower limit, \(\ln 1 - \ln 6 = -\ln 6\), changes its sign, so \(\ln 6\) is added and the answer is \(\ln\dfrac{12}{7}\). This sign slip at the lower limit is an error that examiners' reports mention.
Mark scheme
-
1 mark
B1 The first error is in Line 4: removing the bracket \(-(\ln 1 - \ln 6)\) gives \(+\ln 6\), not \(-\ln 6\) (subtracting \(-\ln 6\) means adding \(\ln 6\)). A correct value of \(\ln\dfrac{12}{7}\) with no working or explanation scores only the last 2 marks.
An answer of \(\ln\dfrac{12}{7}\) with no working scores 2 marks: this mark needs Line 4 identified and the sign error explained. Do not accept a reason that blames Lines 1, 2 or 3, which are all correct. Accept equivalent explanations, e.g. "the minus sign in front of the bracket was not applied to \(-\ln 6\)".
-
1 mark
M1 Removes the brackets correctly and combines the logarithms: \(\ln 2 - \ln 7 + \ln 6\) (or \(\ln 2 - \ln 7 - \ln 1 + \ln 6\)) leading to a single logarithm
-
1 mark
A1 \(\ln\dfrac{12}{7}\)
It must be a single logarithm: \(\ln 12 - \ln 7\) as the final answer is A0, as is a decimal only (awrt 0.539, i.e. [0.5385, 0.5395)).