Source A: Homer, Iliad 18. The god Hephaestus makes a shield for Achilles.
'He threw onto the fire stubborn bronze and tin, and precious gold and silver... On it he set a soft fallow field, rich ploughland, broad and ploughed three times... The field grew dark behind the ploughmen and looked like land that has been ploughed, although it was made of gold: that was a great marvel of the work. On it he set a vineyard heavily laden with grapes, beautiful and golden; the bunches on it were dark, and it stood on silver poles all the way along. Round it he cut a ditch of dark-blue kyanos, and round that ran a fence of tin.'
To what extent do Homer's descriptions of metalwork match the decorative objects found in Mycenaean graves? Use Source A as a starting point and your own knowledge.
Model answer
Source A suggests that Homer's descriptions do have something in common with Mycenaean metalwork. Hephaestus throws bronze, tin, gold and silver into the fire, and the shield combines different metals to make pictures: a field that 'grew dark' although it was gold, a golden vineyard with dark bunches on silver poles, a ditch of kyanos and a fence of tin. This is very like the inlaid dagger blades from the shaft graves at Mycenae, where gold and silver figures were set into a black niello background on bronze - a technique often called 'painting in metal'. Kyanos is probably the blue glass paste found in Mycenaean jewellery and listed on Linear B tablets as decoration on furniture.
Other parts of Homer support this. In Iliad 11 Nestor's cup has golden doves on its handles, and Schliemann found a gold cup with birds on its handles in Shaft Grave IV. In Odyssey 19 Odysseus' gold brooch shows a hound gripping a fawn, very like the scenes of lions attacking deer on the gold pyxis and daggers.
However, the match is not exact. Homer probably composed around the 8th century BC, several centuries after the shaft graves of about 1600-1500 BC, so his poems mix details from different periods. The shield is made by a god and shows whole cities, law courts and dances - far beyond any real object - and the Shaft Grave IV cup has two handles, not four like Nestor's.
Overall, Homer's descriptions match Mycenaean metalwork to a considerable extent in technique and in a few individual objects, which suggests that memories of Mycenaean craftsmanship survived in the oral tradition. But they are poetic and exaggerated, so they cannot be treated as accurate descriptions of real Mycenaean objects.
Explanation
This question links Homer to the archaeology: the best answers pick out the multi-metal technique in the source and compare it with the inlaid daggers, then weigh parallels (Nestor's cup, the brooch) against the long gap in time and the poetic nature of the shield. A clear judgement about how far the match goes is essential for Level 4.