Question 1
1 markA student uses paper chromatography to find the Rf value of a dye in a hair colouring. She uses ethanol as the solvent.
Which change to her experiment would give a different Rf value for the dye?
Choose your answer.
- A letting the solvent run for longer
- B making the spot of hair colouring smaller
- C using a longer piece of the same paper
- D using water instead of ethanol as the solvent
Model answer
D (using water instead of ethanol as the solvent)
Explanation
An Rf value compares how far a substance moves with how far the solvent moves, so it stays the same however long the chromatogram runs or however long the paper is. It depends on how the substance is shared between the mobile phase and the stationary phase. Changing the solvent, for example from a non-aqueous solvent such as ethanol to an aqueous one, changes this, so the same dye has a different Rf value in each solvent.
Mark scheme
-
1 mark
D / using water instead of ethanol as the solvent
The only correct answer is D: the Rf value depends on how the dye is distributed between the solvent (the mobile phase) and the paper (the stationary phase), and a different solvent changes this distribution, so the dye moves a different fraction of the distance moved by the solvent. A is not correct because when the solvent runs for longer the dye also moves further in proportion, so distance moved by dye ÷ distance moved by solvent stays the same; B is not correct because a smaller spot is neater, but its centre still moves the same fraction of the distance moved by the solvent; C is not correct because on the same paper the dye and the solvent behave in the same way whatever the length of the paper, so the Rf value does not change. ALLOW the letter or the option. If more than one option is given, do not award the mark.