Question 1
1 markA scientist wants to check whether a sample of a food dye is a pure substance. She uses paper chromatography and runs the dye in three different solvents.
Which result shows that the food dye is pure?
Choose your answer.
- A a different number of spots in each solvent
- B one spot in each solvent
- C one spot in one solvent and two spots in the others
- D two spots in every solvent
Model answer
B (one spot in each solvent)
Explanation
A pure substance is made of only one substance, so chromatography can never split it into more than one spot. An impure dye might give only one spot in one solvent if its substances happen to move the same distance in that solvent, so testing in several solvents gives stronger evidence. One spot in every solvent shows the dye is pure.
Mark scheme
-
1 mark
B / one spot in each solvent
The only correct answer is B: a pure substance contains only one substance, so it can only give one spot, whichever solvent is used. A is not correct because any solvent that gives more than one spot shows that the dye contains more than one substance; C is not correct because two spots in a solvent show at least two substances, which happened to move the same distance in the other solvent; D is not correct because two spots show that the dye contains at least two substances. ALLOW the letter or the option. If more than one option is given, do not award the mark.