Question 1
2 marksDescribe one feature of Robert's rebellion against his father in the years 1077-80.
Model answer
Robert's rebellion was supported by his father's enemies. King Philip I of France gave Robert the strong castle of Gerberoy, just over the border from Normandy, and from there Robert and his followers raided the duchy until William besieged the castle in 1079.
Explanation
A strong answer picks one aspect of the rebellion, such as how it began, who helped Robert or the fighting at Gerberoy, and supports it with a precise detail. Keep the answer to the rebellion of 1077-80 and do not confuse it with the rebellion against William Rufus in 1088.
Mark scheme
-
1 mark
A valid feature of Robert's rebellion identified, e.g. it began after a quarrel with his brothers at L'Aigle / Robert tried to seize Rouen castle / Robert went into exile with a band of young nobles / he raided Normandy from castles outside the duchy / he was helped by his father's enemies, such as King Philip I of France / Queen Matilda secretly sent him money / Robert defeated his father at Gerberoy (1079) / it ended with a reconciliation in 1080
Award one mark for a valid feature identified. The second mark should be awarded for supporting information. e.g. It began with a family quarrel at L'Aigle (1), when his younger brothers William Rufus and Henry threw water over Robert and his friends (1). / Robert tried to seize Rouen castle (1), but its keeper, Roger d'Ivry, was warned in time and held it for the king (1). / Robert fled into exile (1) with young nobles such as Robert of Bellême and William de Breteuil (1). / Robert raided Normandy (1) from castles outside the duchy such as Rémalard and Gerberoy (1). / He was helped by his father's enemies (1); King Philip I of France gave him the castle of Gerberoy on the Norman border (1). / Queen Matilda secretly sent Robert money (1), which made William furious when he found out (1). / Robert defeated his father at Gerberoy (1), wounding him and unhorsing him (1). / It ended in 1080 (1), when William forgave Robert and confirmed him as heir to Normandy (1). Accept other appropriate features and supporting information.
-
1 mark
Supporting information that develops the feature identified, e.g. for the quarrel: William Rufus and Henry mocked Robert from an upper gallery, a brawl followed and their father had to stop it, but Robert felt humiliated; for Rouen: Robert and his followers rode off in the night and tried to take the castle by surprise, and William ordered their arrest; for the exiles: they included sons of William's own great lords, such as Robert of Bellême (son of Roger of Montgomery) and William de Breteuil (son of William FitzOsbern); for raids: Hugh of Châteauneuf let Robert use his castles, including Rémalard, which William besieged; for foreign help: Robert went to his uncle, Count Robert of Flanders, and Philip I later gave him Gerberoy in the Beauvaisis; for Matilda: she kept sending gold and silver even after William forbade it; for Gerberoy: William besieged the castle in January 1079 but was defeated, and the siege was abandoned; for the reconciliation: Norman nobles, churchmen and Queen Matilda pleaded for peace, and the barons' oaths to Robert as heir to Normandy were renewed
The supporting information must develop the feature already identified. Do not credit a second statement of the same feature in other words, or a general comment such as 'it caused problems'. Orderic Vitalis says the brothers threw water on Robert and his friends (and has Robert's companions call it 'filth'), while many modern accounts say they emptied a chamber pot over him; credit either. Historians date the quarrel at L'Aigle to 1077 or 1078; credit either. Do not credit the claim that the rebellion took place in England, that Robert captured Rouen, that William Rufus or Henry joined Robert (they stayed loyal to their father), that Philip I fought for Robert at the siege of Gerberoy (he had given Robert the castle but then joined William in besieging it), or confusion with the Revolt of the Earls (1075) or the rebellion of 1088.