Question 1
2 marksDescribe one feature of Edgar the Aethling's claim to the throne in 1066.
Model answer
Edgar's claim was based on royal blood, as he belonged to the old English royal family, the house of Wessex. He was the grandson of King Edmund Ironside and the great-nephew of Edward the Confessor, which gave him the closest blood link to the English throne in 1066.
Explanation
A full-mark answer identifies one aspect of Edgar's claim, such as his royal descent or its weakness because of his age, and supports it with a precise detail such as his grandfather Edmund Ironside or his age of about 14. Common errors are to make Edgar the Confessor's son or to say that Edward named him as heir on his deathbed; a long explanation of why the Witan chose Harold is not needed for 2 marks.
Mark scheme
-
1 mark
A valid feature of Edgar's claim identified, e.g. it was based on royal blood: he belonged to the old English royal family, the house of Wessex / he was the grandson of King Edmund Ironside / he was the great-nephew of Edward the Confessor / he was the last male of the royal line / his title 'aethling' showed he was a prince eligible for the throne / his father, Edward the Exile, had been brought home in 1057 as a possible heir / he was brought up at Edward the Confessor's court / the claim was weakened by his youth / he had no lands, army or powerful adult relatives to support it / he had been born and brought up abroad, in Hungary / the Witan passed him over in January 1066
Award one mark for a valid feature identified. The second mark should be awarded for supporting information. e.g. Edgar's claim was based on royal blood (1), as he was the grandson of King Edmund Ironside and the great-nephew of Edward the Confessor (1). / Edgar's father had been brought home as a possible heir (1); Edward the Confessor invited Edward the Exile back from Hungary in 1057, John of Worcester says to make him his heir, but he died soon after arriving (1). / Edgar's claim was weakened by his age (1), as he was only about 14 in 1066 and could not lead an army against invaders (1). / Edgar had no powerful supporters (1); his father was dead and he had no lands or great English family to back him, so the Witan chose Harold instead (1). Accept other appropriate features and supporting information.
-
1 mark
Supporting information that develops the feature identified, e.g. for royal blood: he was the last male of the royal line descended from Alfred the Great, and Edmund Ironside, his grandfather, was king in 1016 and Edward the Confessor's half-brother; for 'aethling': the word meant a prince of the royal family who was eligible to become king; for 1057: Edward the Exile was invited home from Hungary, where he had found refuge after being sent abroad as a baby after Cnut's conquest, but died in London soon after arriving, when Edgar was a small child; for the court: Edgar lived at court with his mother Agatha and his sisters Margaret and Christina, and some historians think Edward saw him as a possible heir; for youth: he was born in about 1052, so he was about 14 when Edward died; for no supporters: his father was dead and his mother and sisters were born abroad, so he had no adult kinsman or great English family to back him; for being passed over: the leading men chose Harold the day after Edward died, although after Hastings Archbishop Ealdred and the Londoners wanted Edgar as king
The supporting information must develop the feature already identified. Do not credit a second statement of the same feature in other words, or a general comment such as 'he was royal' or 'his claim was strong'. Accept 'great-nephew' or 'related to Edward' for the link to Edward the Confessor, and accept 'about 14', 'early teens' or any age from 13 to 15 for his age in 1066. Do not credit claims that Edgar was Edward the Confessor's son or grandson, that he was related to the Godwins or to William of Normandy, that Edward named him as heir on his deathbed, or that he was crowned king in 1066 (some leaders chose him after Hastings, but he was never crowned).