Question 1
2 marksDescribe one feature of marriage among the Norman aristocracy in England.
Model answer
Some Norman lords married English heiresses to strengthen their position in England. For example, Robert d'Oilly married Ealdgyth, the daughter of the English lord Wigod of Wallingford, which linked him to an important English landholding family.
Explanation
Full marks need one clear feature of marriage, such as the need for a lord's permission or marriages to English heiresses, followed by a precise example such as Robert d'Oilly or the marriage of Ralph and Emma in 1075. A common weakness is to say only that marriages were arranged without explaining why or giving an example.
Mark scheme
-
1 mark
A valid feature of aristocratic marriage identified, e.g. marriages were arranged to gain land or make alliances / a lord's permission was needed / the king used marriage to bind great men to him / most Norman lords married Norman or French women / some Normans married English heiresses / some wives stayed in Normandy / noblewomen could hold land and power
Award one mark for a valid feature identified. The second mark should be awarded for supporting information. e.g. Marriages were arranged to gain land and make alliances (1); in 1075 Ralph de Gael, Earl of East Anglia, married Emma, sister of Roger, Earl of Hereford, joining two great families (1). / Great men needed their lord's permission to marry (1); John of Worcester says the marriage of Ralph and Emma went ahead against the king's command (1). / The king used marriage to tie important men to him (1); William gave his niece Judith in marriage to the English earl Waltheof in about 1070 (1). / Most Norman lords married Norman or other French women (1), so their households stayed French in language and customs (1). / Some Normans married English heiresses (1); Robert d'Oilly married Ealdgyth, daughter of the English lord Wigod of Wallingford, linking him to an important English landholding family (1). / Some lords' wives stayed in Normandy (1); Orderic Vitalis says some barons went home in 1068 because their wives demanded it (1). / Noblewomen could hold land (1); Countess Judith held lands in her own right in Domesday Book (1086) (1). Accept other appropriate features and supporting information.
-
1 mark
Supporting information that develops the feature identified, e.g. for alliances: the marriage of Ralph and Emma (1075) joined the earls of East Anglia and Hereford, and the plot of 1075 was made at their wedding feast; for permission: John of Worcester says the marriage was against the king's command (the Anglo-Saxon Chronicle says William gave Emma to Ralph); for the king's use of marriage: Judith, daughter of William's sister, married Earl Waltheof; Orderic says William promised one of his daughters to Earl Edwin; for French wives: Roger de Montgomery married Mabel of Bellême, and William de Warenne married Gundrada; for English heiresses: Robert d'Oilly and Ealdgyth of Wallingford; Orderic and William of Malmesbury both say Normans and English intermarried; for wives in Normandy: Hugh de Grandmesnil and Humphrey de Tilleul went back to Normandy in 1068 (Orderic); for women holding land: Countess Judith is recorded as a landholder in Domesday Book
The supporting information must develop the feature already identified. Do not credit a second statement of the same feature in other words, or a general comment such as 'marriages were important'. The chroniclers disagree about whether William forbade the marriage of Ralph and Emma (John of Worcester) or gave the bride himself (Anglo-Saxon Chronicle); credit either version. Accept 'about 1070' for Judith's marriage to Waltheof. Do not credit the claim that Normans were forbidden to marry English women, that all Norman lords married English heiresses, or that William I married an English woman (Matilda was from Flanders).