Question 1
2 marksDescribe one feature of the role of regents during William I's absences.
Model answer
Regents governed England in the king's name while William was in Normandy, where he spent most of his time after 1072. For example, in 1067 he left his half-brother Odo and his close friend William FitzOsbern in charge, and they built castles to keep the English under control.
Explanation
Full marks need a clear feature, such as who the regents were or what they did, supported by a specific example such as Odo and FitzOsbern in 1067 or Lanfranc in the 1070s. Weaker answers simply define a regent without saying anything about how regents worked under William, or describe Odo's whole career instead of his role as regent.
Mark scheme
-
1 mark
A valid feature of the role of regents identified, e.g. regents governed England in the king's name while William was in Normandy / regents were chosen from William's most trusted men / the regency was often shared by a group of leading men / regents dealt with rebellions and invasions / regents had great power / regents kept in contact with the king by letter / regents could rule harshly / Queen Matilda acted as regent of Normandy when William was in England
Award one mark for a valid feature identified. The second mark should be awarded for supporting information. e.g. Regents governed England in the king's name while William was away (1). After 1072 William spent most of his time in Normandy, so England was often ruled by regents (1). / William chose regents he could trust completely (1), such as his half-brother Bishop Odo and his old friend William FitzOsbern in 1067, and later Archbishop Lanfranc (1). / Regents had to deal with rebellions without the king (1). In 1075 Lanfranc, Odo and other leading men defeated the Revolt of the Earls while William stayed in Normandy (1). / Regents could be harsh rulers (1). Orderic Vitalis said that in 1067 Odo and FitzOsbern ignored the complaints of the English (1). Accept other appropriate features and supporting information.
-
1 mark
Supporting information that develops the feature identified, e.g. for governing: after 1072 William spent most of his time in Normandy, so England was often governed by men acting in his name; for trust: Odo (half-brother), William FitzOsbern (close friend and adviser) in 1067, Lanfranc (Archbishop of Canterbury) on several later occasions; for sharing: Odo and FitzOsbern together in 1067, Lanfranc with barons such as William de Warenne and Richard fitzGilbert in 1075; for rebellions: the Revolt of the Earls (1075) was put down by Lanfranc, Odo, Geoffrey of Coutances, William de Warenne and Richard fitzGilbert; Odo led forces north after Bishop Walcher was killed in 1080; for power: the Anglo-Saxon Chronicle says that when the king was in Normandy, Odo was the mightiest man in the land; for contact: William could still send orders by writ and letter, and Lanfranc reported to him by letter; for harshness: the Anglo-Saxon Chronicle says Odo and FitzOsbern built castles widely and harassed the people in 1067, Orderic says they ignored English complaints, and there was unrest in Kent and Herefordshire; for Matilda: she governed Normandy for William when he was in England, with the help of a council
The supporting information must develop the feature already identified. Do not credit a second statement of the same feature in other words, or general comments such as 'regents were important'. Do not credit the claim that regents could overrule the king or that regents were elected. Answers about one regent (for example Odo) are acceptable if they describe the role of a regent, not just his career. Accept 'most of his time' or 'about three-quarters of his time' for William's time in Normandy after 1072. Do not credit Matilda as regent of England unless the answer is clearly about her rule of Normandy.