Question 1
2 marksDescribe one feature of the position Harold's army held at the Battle of Hastings.
Model answer
Harold's army held the top of a ridge, Senlac Hill. This meant that the Norman archers, foot soldiers and knights all had to attack up a steep slope, while marshy ground and woods protected the ends of the English line.
Explanation
Two marks need one clear feature of the position, such as the ridge or the protected flanks, with a supporting detail that explains or illustrates it. Be precise about place: the battle was fought several miles inland from Hastings, at what is now Battle, not in the town of Hastings.
Mark scheme
-
1 mark
A valid feature of the English position identified, e.g. it was on top of a ridge (Senlac Hill / Battle Hill) / the Normans had to attack up a slope / the flanks were protected by marshy ground, streams and woods / it blocked the road from Hastings to London / the English were packed tightly on a narrow front / it was a few miles inland from Hastings / Battle Abbey was later built on it
Award one mark for a valid feature identified. The second mark should be awarded for supporting information. e.g. Harold's army stood on top of a ridge, Senlac Hill (1), so the Normans had to attack up a steep slope (1). / The ends of the English line were protected (1) by marshy ground, streams and woods, so the Normans could not easily get round them (1). / The position blocked the road from Hastings to London (1), so William could not march inland without fighting (1). / The English were packed tightly on a narrow front (1); John of Worcester says they were crowded in a confined position and many left their ranks (1). / The position became the site of Battle Abbey (1), which William founded, with its high altar said to mark the place where Harold fell (1). Accept other appropriate features and supporting information.
-
1 mark
Supporting information that develops the feature identified, e.g. for the ridge: the slope slowed Norman infantry and made cavalry charges and uphill archery less effective; for the flanks: marsh and woods meant attacks had to be made from the front; for the road: the London road ran along the spur behind the ridge, and the English had probably gathered the night before on Caldbec Hill, which may be the Chronicle's 'hoary apple tree'; for the packed front: a dense formation made the shield wall strong but left little room to move, and men at the back were exposed to arrows shot high; for the distance: the site is about 6-9 miles (about 10-14 km) north-west of Hastings, in the modern town of Battle; for Battle Abbey: twelfth-century sources say the high altar was placed where Harold was killed
The supporting information must develop the feature already identified. Do not credit a second statement of the same feature in other words, or a general comment such as 'it was a good position'. Accept Senlac Hill, Battle Hill or 'the ridge at Battle'. Accept distances from about 6 to 9 miles from Hastings (John of Worcester says nine miles). Do not credit claims that Harold fought at Hastings itself or at Pevensey, that the English held a river crossing (that was Stamford Bridge), or that the Normans held the hill.