'Pikuach nefesh shows that saving a life is more important than obeying God's laws.'
Evaluate this statement.
In your answer you should:
- refer to Jewish teaching
- give reasoned arguments to support this statement
- give reasoned arguments to support a different point of view
- reach a justified conclusion.
[12 marks]
[+ 3 SPaG marks]
Model answer
There is a strong case for agreeing with this statement. Pikuach nefesh allows, and in fact requires, Jews to set aside almost every mitzvah in order to save a life. A Jew must break Shabbat to drive a sick person to hospital, must eat on Yom Kippur if fasting would endanger their health, and may take non-kosher medicine to save a life. The Talmud says that whoever is quick to break Shabbat to save a life is praiseworthy and does not need to ask permission (Yoma 84b), and the Mishnah teaches that saving one life is like saving an entire world (Sanhedrin 4:5). This seems to show that human life matters more than even the most important rituals of Judaism, which is why Jewish doctors and Hatzola volunteers answer emergency calls on Shabbat.
However, there are good reasons to disagree. Saving life is not a break from God's law; it is itself one of God's laws. The rabbis base pikuach nefesh on Leviticus 18:5, where God says a person who keeps the commandments 'shall live by them', and they add 'and not die by them' (Yoma 85b). The Torah also commands 'neither shalt thou stand idly by the blood of thy neighbour' (Leviticus 19:16). So a Jew who breaks Shabbat to save a life is obeying God, not disobeying him. The Talmud even explains that it is right to break one Shabbat for someone so that they can keep many Shabbatot in the future (Yoma 85b), so the purpose of pikuach nefesh is to allow more mitzvot to be kept. Most importantly, the three exceptions show that some laws are more important than life: a Jew must die rather than worship idols, commit murder or commit forbidden sexual acts (Sanhedrin 74a). Throughout history some Jews have chosen martyrdom rather than abandon their faith, which shows that life is not valued above everything.
In conclusion, I disagree with the statement. Pikuach nefesh does show that life is extremely precious, more precious than most rituals. But it does not put life above God's law; rather, it shows that God's law was given for the sake of life. Saving a life is an act of obedience to God, and the three exceptions show that faithfulness to God remains the highest value.
Explanation
The most sophisticated answers spot that pikuach nefesh is itself a commandment, so saving life can be seen as obeying God rather than overriding God's law. Using the three exceptions in Sanhedrin 74a is a powerful counter-argument. Make sure the conclusion follows from the reasoning rather than restating the statement.