'The promise of land is the most important part of the Covenant with Abraham.'
Evaluate this statement.
In your answer you should:
- refer to Jewish teaching
- give reasoned arguments to support this statement
- give reasoned arguments to support a different point of view
- reach a justified conclusion.
[12 marks]
[+ 3 SPaG marks]
Model answer
There are strong reasons to agree. The promise of land is repeated more often than any other part of the Covenant: God promises it in Genesis 12:1 and 12:7, again in 13:15 and 15:18, and in Genesis 17:8 calls it 'an everlasting possession'. A nation needs a land in order to live fully by the Torah, because many mitzvot, such as the sabbatical year and the tithes, can only be kept there, and the Temple, where the Shekhinah dwelt, stood in Jerusalem. The whole story of the Torah moves towards the land, and for almost two thousand years of exile Jews prayed to return, ending the Seder with 'Next year in Jerusalem'. The Talmud teaches that a person should always live in the land of Israel (Ketubot 110b), and religious Zionists see the land as central to the Covenant's fulfilment.
However, other parts of the Covenant could be seen as more important. At its heart is the relationship with God: God promises 'to be a God unto thee, and to thy seed after thee' (Genesis 17:7). Without the promise of descendants, there would be no nation to inherit the land at all. The promise that through Abraham 'all families of the earth' will be blessed (Genesis 12:3) gives the Covenant a purpose for the whole world, not just one territory. The sign God chose for the Covenant was circumcision (Genesis 17:11), not the land. Most strikingly, Jews kept the Covenant faithfully for two thousand years while living outside the land, which shows that it can be lived without it. Many Reform and Liberal Jews emphasise the ethical mission of the Covenant, and the early Reform Pittsburgh Platform of 1885 even said that Jews no longer expected to return to the land.
In conclusion, I disagree with the statement. The land is a vital part of the Covenant, and the Torah's repeated promises show how much it matters. But the relationship between God and Abraham's descendants is the foundation on which every other promise rests, and Jewish history in exile proves that this relationship survived without the land. The land is the most visible promise, but the relationship with God is the most important.
Explanation
High-level answers compare the land with the other parts of the Covenant, such as descendants, blessing and the relationship with God, using references like Genesis 17:7-8. A strong argument uses Jewish history, such as faithfulness in exile, as evidence, and the conclusion should follow from the reasoning. Avoid long discussion of current politics, which earns no credit here.