'Jews should work to bring about the Messianic age rather than wait for the Messiah.'
Evaluate this statement.
In your answer you should:
- refer to Jewish teaching
- give reasoned arguments to support this statement
- give reasoned arguments to support a different point of view
- reach a justified conclusion.
[12 marks]
[+ 3 SPaG marks]
Model answer
Many Jews would agree with this statement. Reform and Liberal Jews generally believe in a Messianic age rather than a personal Messiah, and that this age will come through human work for justice and peace, which they call tikkun olam. The Aleinu prayer speaks of perfecting the world under the kingdom of God, which suggests that humans have a part to play. Even traditional sources link redemption to human action: Rabbi Eliezer taught that 'if the Jewish people repent they are redeemed' (Sanhedrin 97b), and the Talmud tells of the Messiah saying he will come 'today, if ye will hear his voice' (Sanhedrin 98a). Chabad Hasidim, who strongly believe in a personal Messiah, still work actively to hasten his coming by encouraging Jews to keep mitzvot. Rabbi Yohanan ben Zakkai taught that someone planting a sapling should finish planting before going to greet the Messiah, showing that present duties matter more than waiting. The history of false messiahs such as Shabbetai Tzvi also warns against simply waiting for one person.
However, many Orthodox Jews would disagree. They believe the Messiah will be sent by God at the time God chooses: 'I the LORD will hasten it in his time' (Isaiah 60:22). Maimonides' twelfth principle commits Jews to wait daily for the Messiah, and he wrote that anyone who does not await his coming denies the Torah itself (Laws of Kings 11:1). Rabbi Yehoshua taught that redemption will come even if Israel does not repent (Sanhedrin 97b), and the 'three oaths' in Ketubot 111a warn Jews not to try to force the end. Many Haredi Jews believe that tasks such as rebuilding the Temple and gathering the exiles belong to the Messiah alone, and that human attempts to create a perfect world have often failed.
In conclusion, I think the statement sets up a false choice. Orthodox Jews wait for the Messiah but also keep the mitzvot in the hope of bringing him closer, while Reform Jews work for the Messianic age but still express hope in their prayers. However, the strongest Jewish teaching is that waiting must never mean doing nothing, as Rabbi Yohanan ben Zakkai's sapling shows. So Jews should work for a better world while trusting God to complete it, rather than choose one over the other.
Explanation
Top answers contrast Reform and Liberal views of a human-made Messianic age with Orthodox belief in a Messiah sent at God's time, and notice that Orthodox Jews also see mitzvot as hastening redemption. Use named teachings, such as Sanhedrin 97b or Maimonides, within the arguments. A conclusion that recognises the false choice in 'rather than', and explains why, is a mark of a high-level answer.