'Healing the world (tikkun olam) is more about social action than about keeping the mitzvot.'
Evaluate this statement.
In your answer you should:
- refer to Jewish teaching
- give reasoned arguments to support this statement
- give reasoned arguments to support a different point of view
- reach a justified conclusion.
[12 marks]
[+ 3 SPaG marks]
Model answer
Many Jews today would agree with this statement. In Reform and Liberal Judaism especially, tikkun olam usually means social action: working against poverty, supporting refugees and protecting the environment. Projects such as Mitzvah Day bring thousands of volunteers together to help their local communities, and this is what most people now mean by healing the world. There is support for this view in Jewish teaching. The prophets taught that God rejects worship from people who ignore the poor (Amos 5:21-24), and in the Mishnah the phrase 'for the sake of tikkun ha-olam' is used for practical laws made to improve the order of society. A midrash tells how God showed Adam the Garden of Eden and warned him not to ruin the world, because there would be no one to repair it after him (Kohelet Rabbah 7:13). On this view, healing the world means practical action to make society fairer and to protect creation.
However, other Jews, particularly many Orthodox Jews, would disagree. The Aleinu prayer, said at the end of every service, speaks of perfecting the world 'under the kingdom of the Almighty', a world that recognises God, and this is brought about through worship and keeping the mitzvot. In the Kabbalah of Isaac Luria, every mitzvah, including ritual ones such as prayer, Shabbat and kashrut, gathers sparks of holiness that were scattered when the world was broken, so each mitzvah repairs the world in a spiritual way. Furthermore, the statement creates a false division, because social action is itself commanded: tzedakah, loving the stranger and pursuing justice are all mitzvot. A Jew who gives tzedakah or helps a refugee is keeping the mitzvot at the same time as taking social action.
In conclusion, I disagree with the statement. It is true that in modern usage tikkun olam is strongly linked with social action, and this practical side is important. However, the Aleinu and the Kabbalah show that healing the world has also long been understood as bringing the whole world closer to God, and the mitzvot, both ethical and ritual, are the main way Jews do this. Social action is best seen as one part of keeping the mitzvot, not an alternative to it.
Explanation
Top-level answers show that tikkun olam is understood differently, as social action in much Reform and Liberal thought and as the spiritual effect of all the mitzvot in Orthodox and Kabbalistic thought. Using sources such as the Aleinu or Amos makes the reasoning convincing. Pointing out that social action is itself commanded by the mitzvot is a strong evaluative move.