'Fasting is the most important part of Yom Kippur.'
Evaluate this statement.
In your answer you should:
- refer to Jewish teaching
- give reasoned arguments to support this statement
- give reasoned arguments to support a different point of view
- reach a justified conclusion.
Model answer
Some Jews would agree that fasting is the most important part of Yom Kippur. The Torah commands, 'ye shall afflict your souls' (Leviticus 16:29), and the rabbis understood this mainly as fasting from food and drink for about 25 hours. The fast is the most noticeable part of the day and is kept by almost all adult Jews who are healthy enough, so it unites the whole community. By turning away from food and physical comforts, Jews are able to focus on their souls and on God, which makes their prayers more sincere. Fasting also shows that they take their sins seriously. In the Book of Jonah, which is read on Yom Kippur afternoon, the people of Nineveh fasted and turned from their evil ways, and God forgave them (Jonah 3:5-10), showing that fasting can be part of true repentance.
However, many Jews would argue that fasting is only a means to something more important. On Yom Kippur morning Jews read Isaiah 58, in which God asks, 'Is it such a fast that I have chosen?' and explains that the true fast is 'to loose the bands of wickedness' and to feed the hungry. This shows that fasting without changed behaviour is worthless. The Unetaneh Tokef prayer teaches that it is repentance, prayer and charity that avert a harsh decree. The Mishnah teaches that Yom Kippur does not atone for wrongs done to other people until they have been put right (Yoma 8:9), so reconciliation is essential. The confession of sins and the final Neilah service, when the gates of repentance are pictured as closing, are the spiritual heart of the day. Finally, people who cannot fast for health reasons still keep Yom Kippur fully, because Pikuach Nefesh puts life first, which shows fasting is not the essence of the festival.
In conclusion, I disagree with the statement. Fasting is important because it is commanded and it helps Jews to focus, but its purpose is to support repentance. As Isaiah 58 shows, a fast without genuine change means nothing to God, so teshuvah - turning back to God and putting things right with others - is the most important part of Yom Kippur.
Explanation
The best answers weigh fasting against repentance, prayer, charity and reconciliation, and use teachings such as Leviticus 16:29, Isaiah 58 and Mishnah Yoma 8:9 as evidence. Pointing out that those who cannot fast still keep the day fully is a strong evaluative point. A list of Yom Kippur activities, without judging which matters most, will not reach the higher levels.