'Keeping kosher is too difficult for Jews in Britain today.'
Evaluate this statement.
In your answer you should:
- refer to Jewish teaching
- give reasoned arguments to support this statement
- give reasoned arguments to support a different point of view
- reach a justified conclusion.
Model answer
Some Jews in Britain would agree that keeping kosher is too difficult today. Kosher butchers, shops and restaurants are found mainly in parts of London and Manchester, so Jews who live elsewhere may have to travel long distances or order food from far away. Kosher meat often costs more than ordinary meat because of the cost of shechitah and supervision. Social life can also be hard: eating with non-Jewish friends, at school dinners or at work events may mean bringing their own food or eating very little. A kosher home needs two sets of crockery, cutlery and pans, and many Jews wait several hours after eating meat before having dairy food, which takes effort and planning. Some Reform and Liberal Jews believe the dietary laws belonged to an earlier age, so they do not think such effort is required, and some keep 'kosher-style' instead, avoiding pork and shellfish but not buying certified meat.
However, many Jews would argue that keeping kosher in Britain is easier now than ever before. Supermarkets stock kosher products, many everyday foods carry a hechsher, kashrut authorities publish guides to approved products, and kosher food can be delivered almost anywhere. Some schools, hospitals and airlines provide kosher meals, and vegetarian or fish dishes make eating out possible. For Orthodox Jews the question of difficulty misses the point: kashrut is a command from God, given so that Jews may be holy, as God says, 'ye shall be holy; for I am holy' (Leviticus 11:44). Keeping the laws when it is inconvenient is a sign of faith and commitment, and Jews have kept them through far harder times in their history. Jewish law also has limits: the principle of Pikuach Nefesh means the food laws are set aside if a life is in danger, so they never demand the impossible.
In conclusion, I disagree with the statement. Keeping kosher in Britain takes effort, especially for Jews who live far from a Jewish community, but supermarkets, certification and community support make it achievable for anyone who chooses to do it. Whether the effort is worthwhile depends on a Jew's beliefs: for Orthodox Jews it is a duty to God, while for many Reform Jews it is a personal choice. Either way, the difficulty is real but not too great.
Explanation
Good answers use specific evidence about life in Britain, such as where kosher shops are found and how certification helps, and then apply Jewish teaching to the question of difficulty. Including both Orthodox and Reform or Liberal views shows the range of Jewish opinion. The conclusion should judge whether the difficulty is 'too' great, not just agree that keeping kosher takes effort.