'The Ten Commandments are no longer relevant to Jews living in Britain today.'
Evaluate this statement.
In your answer you should:
- refer to Jewish teaching
- give reasoned arguments to support this statement
- give reasoned arguments to support a different point of view
- reach a justified conclusion.
[12 marks]
[+ 3 SPaG marks]
Model answer
Some people might argue that the Ten Commandments are no longer relevant to Jews in Britain. They were given more than three thousand years ago to a people who had just escaped slavery, and some of their wording reflects that world: the last commandment forbids coveting a neighbour's 'man-servant' or 'ox'. Many of the moral commandments, such as not murdering, stealing or giving false evidence in court, are already part of British law, so a Jew would keep them anyway. Keeping Shabbat can also be very difficult in a society where shops open every day and many jobs, sports fixtures and even some exams take place on Saturdays, and some British Jews are secular and do not keep Shabbat at all.
However, most Jews would strongly disagree. Orthodox Jews believe the Ten Commandments are God's eternal words, spoken to the whole people at Sinai, and that the covenant was made with every future generation too (Deuteronomy 29:14-15), so they cannot go out of date. Reform and Liberal Jews, who adapt some ritual laws, still see the ethical commandments as the heart of Judaism; the 1885 Pittsburgh Platform of American Reform Judaism said Reform Jews 'accept as binding only its moral laws', and the Ten Commandments are the clearest of those laws. The principles behind them are as relevant as ever. 'Honour thy father and thy mother' matters in an ageing society where many older people are lonely. 'Thou shalt not covet' speaks directly to a culture of advertising and consumer pressure. Many rabbis teach that the ban on idols applies to money, celebrity or social media when they take over a person's life. Shabbat, far from being outdated, gives Jews a weekly break from work and screens, which many people value for family life and wellbeing. The fact that British law forbids murder and theft does not make the commandments irrelevant; it shows how deeply they have shaped society.
In conclusion, I disagree with the statement. A few details of the wording reflect the ancient world, and some commandments, such as Shabbat, are harder to keep in modern Britain, but the values they express are timeless. Both Orthodox and Progressive Jews see them as a living part of the covenant, which is why the two tablets are still displayed in synagogues and the Ten Commandments are still read aloud at Shavuot.
Explanation
High-level answers apply specific commandments to life in Britain today rather than speaking generally, and show how Orthodox and Reform Jews understand their authority differently. Give the supporting side real reasons, such as the difficulty of keeping Shabbat, before weighing them. A justified conclusion explains which arguments are strongest and why.