'Giving the ring is the most important part of a Jewish wedding.'
Evaluate this statement.
In your answer you should:
- refer to Jewish teaching
- give reasoned arguments to support this statement
- give reasoned arguments to support a different point of view
- reach a justified conclusion.
Model answer
Some Jews would agree that giving the ring is the most important part of a Jewish wedding, because in Jewish law it is the moment the marriage is actually made. According to the Mishnah and Talmud (Kiddushin 1:1; Kiddushin 2a), a marriage is created when the groom gives the bride an object of value in front of two witnesses. Under the chuppah he places the ring on her finger and says, 'Behold, you are consecrated to me with this ring according to the law of Moses and Israel.' Without this act of kiddushin, there is no marriage in Orthodox law. The word kiddushin means holiness, showing that this is when the couple are set apart for each other before God. The plain, unbroken ring also symbolises a whole and lasting commitment. Other parts of the day, such as breaking the glass, are customs that could be left out without affecting whether the couple are married.
However, others would argue that the ring is only one essential part. A Jewish wedding has two stages: betrothal (kiddushin) and marriage (nissuin), and the marriage is only completed under the chuppah when the seven blessings are said. The seven blessings put God at the centre of the ceremony, praising God for creating human beings and joy, which many would see as more important than any object. The ketubah is also essential: in Orthodox Judaism a couple may not live together without one, because it protects the wife by setting out her husband's duties. Witnesses are needed for the marriage to be valid at all. Reform Jews might argue that the most important part is the promises both partners make to each other, which is why they exchange rings and often use a ketubah with equal promises. Others would say that what matters most is not any ritual but the couple's commitment to build a loving Jewish home.
In conclusion, I think giving the ring is the most important single moment in Orthodox law, because it is the act that creates the marriage. However, it is not the most important part overall, because the ring only has meaning within the whole ceremony, which together with the ketubah, the witnesses and the seven blessings sets the marriage within God's law. So I partly agree: the ring makes the marriage, but the rest of the ceremony shows what that marriage is for.
Explanation
Top answers know why the ring matters in Jewish law (kiddushin) and weigh it against other essential parts, such as the ketubah, the witnesses and the seven blessings, using teaching such as Talmud Kiddushin 2a. Referring to Orthodox and Reform differences, such as the exchange of rings, shows awareness of diversity. The conclusion should judge which part is most important and explain why, rather than just listing parts of the wedding.