'Sacraments are not necessary for Christians to receive God's grace.'
Evaluate this statement.
In your answer you should:
- refer to Christian teaching
- give reasoned arguments to support this statement
- give reasoned arguments to support a different point of view
- reach a justified conclusion.
Model answer
Some Christians agree with this statement. Quakers believe that God's grace is received inwardly and directly through the Holy Spirit, so they do not use outward sacraments at all; instead they see the whole of life as sacramental. The Salvation Army stopped celebrating the sacraments in 1883, partly so that people would not rely on a ritual instead of real faith, and its members show their faith through committed service to others. Paul taught that Christians are saved by grace through faith, 'not of works' (Ephesians 2:8-9), which suggests God's grace does not depend on a ceremony. The criminal crucified beside Jesus was promised paradise without being baptised (Luke 23:43). Many Baptists also see baptism and the Lord's Supper as ordinances which symbolise grace a believer has already received, rather than giving grace themselves.
However, Catholic and Orthodox Christians strongly disagree. The Catechism describes the sacraments as 'efficacious signs of grace, instituted by Christ' (CCC 1131), meaning they actually give the grace they show, and it teaches that for believers they are necessary for salvation (CCC 1129). Jesus commanded his followers to baptise (Matthew 28:19) and to share bread and wine in remembrance of him (Luke 22:19), so Christians who ignore the sacraments are not following his instructions. Jesus also said, 'Whoso eateth my flesh, and drinketh my blood, hath eternal life' (John 6:54). These Christians argue that because humans are physical beings, God gives grace through physical signs such as water, bread and wine, just as he came to earth in a human body. Anglicans and Methodists agree that baptism and Holy Communion are important means of grace, and the Book of Common Prayer calls them 'generally necessary to salvation'.
It is worth noting that even the Catechism says that God 'is not bound by his sacraments' (CCC 1257). So most Christians accept that God can give grace without sacraments in special cases, but believe the sacraments are the normal way he has chosen.
In conclusion, I disagree with the statement for most Christians. God is free to give grace in any way, as the Quakers and the Salvation Army show, so sacraments are not the only route to grace. But because Jesus himself commanded baptism and Holy Communion, most Christians believe they are the ordinary and reliable way to receive God's grace, and so, for them, they are necessary.
Explanation
This statement rewards precise knowledge of diversity: Quaker and Salvation Army views, the Baptist idea of ordinances, and Catholic and Orthodox teaching that sacraments are effective signs of grace. Top answers apply sources such as CCC 1131, Ephesians 2:8-9 and Jesus' commands, and notice the nuance that God 'is not bound by his sacraments'. Avoid simply describing sacraments without judging whether they are necessary.