'Innocent suffering shows that God is not just.'
Evaluate this statement.
In your answer you should:
- refer to Christian teaching
- give reasoned arguments to support this statement
- give reasoned arguments to support a different point of view
- reach a justified conclusion.
[12 marks]
[+ 3 SPaG marks]
Model answer
Some people, including some Christians who are struggling with their faith, would agree with this statement. Many people suffer terribly even though they have done nothing to deserve it, such as a young child with cancer or a family killed in an earthquake. If God is just, he should treat people according to what they deserve, and if he is omnipotent he could stop this suffering. The Bible itself takes this problem seriously: Job protests that the wicked live long and prosper while he suffers, and the writer of Psalm 73 is troubled by 'the prosperity of the wicked'. Free will may explain why people suffer from war or crime, but it cannot explain natural evil, so it seems that innocent suffering really does count against God's justice.
However, most Christians would disagree. They believe God's justice is not limited to this life. Jesus taught that everyone will be judged (Matthew 25:31-46), and Revelation promises that God 'shall wipe away all tears' (Revelation 21:4), so the innocent will be comforted and wrongs put right after death. Jesus also rejected the idea that suffering is a punishment for personal sin, saying of a man born blind that neither he nor his parents had sinned (John 9:3). Much innocent suffering is caused by human choices, so the injustice belongs to people, not to God. Christians also point to the cross: Jesus was completely innocent, yet he was crucified, and God brought the resurrection out of that suffering. This shows that God is not distant from innocent suffering but shares in it. Catholic teaching admits there is no quick answer to evil (CCC 309), and the Book of Job suggests that God's wisdom is beyond human understanding.
In conclusion, I disagree with the statement. Innocent suffering is a real and painful challenge, and the argument for the statement would be strong if this life were all there is. But Christians believe God's justice works over the whole of a person's existence, including life after death, and that God himself entered innocent suffering in Jesus. If those beliefs are true, innocent suffering shows that God's justice is not yet complete, not that God is unjust.
Explanation
The best answers explain why innocent suffering challenges God's justice, then evaluate Christian responses such as judgement after death, free will and the innocent suffering of Jesus, rather than retelling the problem of evil in general. Make the conclusion follow from the arguments, for example by deciding whether belief in an afterlife really answers the challenge. Avoid saying that all suffering is a punishment for sin, which most Christians reject because of passages such as John 9:3.