'Christians should accept the scientific explanation of how the universe began.'
Evaluate this statement.
In your answer you should:
- refer to Christian teaching
- give reasoned arguments to support this statement
- give reasoned arguments to support a different point of view
- reach a justified conclusion.
[12 marks]
[+ 3 SPaG marks]
Model answer
Many Christians would agree with this statement. The scientific evidence for the Big Bang, such as the expansion of the universe and the background radiation left over from it, is very strong, and so is the evidence for evolution. These Christians argue that science and religion answer different questions: science explains how the universe began, while Genesis explains why it exists and who made it. The Catholic Church accepts both the Big Bang and evolution; Pope Francis said in 2014 that the Big Bang does not contradict belief in a divine creator, and the Catechism describes the six days of Genesis as symbolic (CCC 337). The theory was first proposed by Georges Lemaitre, a Catholic priest, which shows that faith and science can work together. The Church of England and many Orthodox Christians take a similar view, and as long ago as the fifth century Augustine warned Christians against interpreting Genesis in ways that contradict what can be known about the natural world.
However, other Christians disagree. Young earth creationists, who are mostly evangelical Protestants, believe the Bible is the inerrant word of God, so Genesis 1 must be accepted as it stands: God created everything in six days, a few thousand years ago. They argue that if Genesis is not literally true, people may doubt other parts of the Bible, such as the Fall, which explains why humans need salvation (Romans 5:12). They point out that scientific theories change, while 'the word of our God shall stand for ever' (Isaiah 40:8). Some Christians also argue that science cannot explain what caused the Big Bang or why there is a universe at all, so accepting 'the scientific explanation' on its own leaves out God.
In conclusion, I agree that Christians should accept the scientific explanation, as long as it is not taken to rule out God. The literalist argument is sincere, but it depends on reading Genesis as science, which many Christians since Augustine have believed it was never meant to be. Accepting the Big Bang does not stop a Christian believing that God is the creator; it simply describes the method God used. Science answers how the universe began and faith answers why, so the two can fit together.
Explanation
Top answers show diversity within Christianity, for example contrasting young earth creationists with Catholic and Anglican acceptance of the Big Bang and evolution, and support each view with specific teaching such as CCC 337 or Isaiah 40:8. The conclusion should weigh the arguments, for instance by asking whether science and Genesis are really answering the same question. Avoid suggesting that all Christians reject science or that accepting science means rejecting God.